关于prep里的一题

Monkey.D.Vivi

Surveys have shown that in up to 40 percent of elderly peopleliving independently in affluent

countries, the consumption of one or more essential nutrientsis insufficient or they have deficient

levels of these nutrients in their blood.

(A) in up to 40 percent of elderly people living independentlyin affluent countries, the consumption

of one or more essential nutrients is insufficient or theyhave

(B) in up to 40 percent of elderly people who liveindependently in affluent countries, they consume

one or more essential nutrients insufficiently or have

(C) in up to 40 percent of elderly people who liveindependently in affluent countries, one or more

essential nutrients are consumed insufficiently or having

(D) up to 40 percent of elderly people living independently inaffluent countries who consume

insufficient amounts of one or more essential nutrients or whohave

(E) up to 40 percent of elderly people who live independentlyin affluent countries consume

insufficient amounts of one or more essential nutrients orhave

who不是只能指代人吗？这样的话D选项who引导的定语从句应该是修饰人而不是countries?而老prep对D的解释只是WHO修饰countries，表示有点小郁闷。我觉得who没有错，错误点在这句话缺少谓语，求大神指教

kiwifoodtown

同意LZ，D选项最主要的错误是从句内无谓语动词，但who的指代从严格的意义上来说也是个问题。

Monkey.D.Vivi

kiwifoodtown 发表于 2013-6-9 09:08
同意LZ，D选项最主要的错误是从句内无谓语动词，但who的指代从严格的意义上来说也是个问题。 ...

为嘛会有问题啊？您老的这个严格意义上的措辞好那个啥，对，就是那个形容词

kiwifoodtown

Monkey.D.Vivi 发表于 2013-6-9 12:39
为嘛会有问题啊？您老的这个严格意义上的措辞好那个啥，对，就是那个形容词 ...

因为，WHO的确在这里有修饰countries的嫌疑，但这不是重点，因为从句没有谓语这一点错误就足够排除选项了。

Monkey.D.Vivi

kiwifoodtown 发表于 2013-6-9 14:03
因为，WHO的确在这里有修饰countries的嫌疑，但这不是重点，因为从句没有谓语这一点错误就足够排除选项了 ...

感人啊！谢谢你理我哦！姐姐还有好多疑问呢，等待赐教

kiwifoodtown

Monkey.D.Vivi 发表于 2013-6-9 18:18
感人啊！谢谢你理我哦！姐姐还有好多疑问呢，等待赐教

不会不理你的，有问题一起探讨。