求解GWD-23-Q23 ing伴随题/(ㄒoㄒ)/~~

linlongzakes

GWD-23-Q23

After several years of rapidgrowth, the healthy care company became one of the largest health careproviders in the metropolitan area, while it then proved unable to handlethe increase in business, falling months behind in its payment to doctorsand hospitals.

错选A  

• [url=]while[/url][CH1] it then proved unable to handle the increase in     business, falling months behind in its payment to
  
• [url=]while[/url][CH2] it then proved unable to handle the increase in     business and fell months behind in its payment to
  
• but then it proved unable to handle the increase     in business, falling months behind in [url=]its paying[/url][CH3]
  
• but then [url=]proving unable[/url][CH4] to     handle the increase in business, falling months behind in paying
  
• but then proved unable to handle the increase     in business, falling months behind in paying
  

---

[CH1]承前转折用but

[CH2]同A

[CH3]one’s doing错

[CH4]but后面接句子

答案是E 错选A  但是觉得A 的理由很牵强。。。是不是A 用while分句后面再加伴随ing会造成歧义？

求大神赐教！！！

bejamin1111

我觉得a的最大问题是while的存在改变了句子的intended meaning, 原句的意思是在成为最大的provider之后无法handle the increase,而while表示在成为最大的这个过程中就无法handle,不对。还有，in its payment没有in paying简洁

linlongzakes

while /waɪl/ CET4 TEM4
1. CONJIf something happens while something else is happening, the two things are happening at the same time. 当…的时候 (表示两事同时发生)

例：They were grinning and watching while one man laughed and poured beer over the head of another.
当一个男人大笑着将啤酒倒在另一个男人头上时，他们正边看边咧着嘴笑。

例：I sat on the chair to unwrap the package while he stood behind me.
我坐在椅子上打开包裹，当时他就站在我身后。

2. CONJIf something happens while something else happens, the first thing happens at some point during the time that the second thing is happening. 正值…之时 (表示一件事是在另一件事发生过程中的某个时间发生的)

例：The two ministers have yet to meet, but may do so while in New York.
两位部长还未会面，但他们在纽约期间可能会见面。

3. CONJYou use while at the beginning of a clause to introduce information that contrasts with information in the main clause. 而 (用于从句之首，引出与主句内容相对比的信息)

例：Most digital camera owners are male, while women prefer film.
大部分数码相机的主人都是男性，而女性偏爱用胶卷。

4. CONJYou use while, before making a statement, in order to introduce information that partly conflicts with your statement. 虽然 (用于发表陈述之前，引入和陈述内容部分矛盾的信息)

例：While the news, so far, has been good, there may be days ahead when it is bad.
虽然到目前为止都是好消息，但是可能过几天就有坏消息了。

NOUN AND VERB USESwhile /waɪl/ (whiling, whiled, whiles)
1. N-SINGA while is a period of time. 一段时间

例：They walked on in silence for a while.
他们默默地走了一会儿。

例：He was married a little while ago.
他前不久刚结了婚。

2. PHRASEYou use all the while in order to say that something happens continually or that it happens throughout the time when something else is happening. 一直

例：All the while the people at the next table watched me eat.
邻桌的人一直在看着我吃东西。

我在有道上查的语法规则

我觉得这个句子的while适用于conj. 第三条解释。。。但是一定要找出原因的话可能是就是句子应该强调的是它无法及时支付，用while貌似在强调前半句，有尽管的感觉。。。语法真是玄妙。。。
anyway 感谢楼上童鞋的解答

enkyklios

linlongzakes 发表于 2013-5-24 23:04
while /waɪl/ CET4 TEM4
1. CONJIf something happens while something else is happening, the two thing ...

官方的回答虽然是简单了点，但是并没有错。
这儿绝对不能用while.
其实楼主不喜欢用搜索，我在论坛里回复过这个问题。
while用于转折的时候，只能在横向比较，不能在时间轴上纵向的比较。归根到底这和while的”同时“有关，
我还用我举过的例子； ” 我很帅，while 他很丑“。但是你不要说，”昨天这个问题我不会做，while 现在我会做了“。
有了时间先后的概念不能用while.  这个时间的先后我想就是官方回答中所说的承前。尽管你上边举了那么多while的例子，但是你对照一下我说的就会发现并没有一个破坏这个规则的

语法其实就是把玄妙的东西规范起来，让我们有迹可寻。如果连语法都玄妙了那就没有办法学习了。所以不要把一个问题想的太过复杂

linlongzakes

原来是 时间先后 还是同时 的问题。。受教！！

原来CD还有搜索功能。。。不常逛的小白一只。。。

感谢enkyklios 解答~\(≧▽≦)/~ 终于明白了！