老prep 102一道题。。本人不才。。

zikuier

102. (29983-!-item-!-188;#058&004080)

Recent breakthroughs in technology have made it possible that high-definition digital video cameras are able to capture material with a degree of fidelity that nearly compares to 35-millimeter film and to project it digitally in theaters with no resulting loss of image quality.



(A) it possible that high-definition digital video cameras are able to capture material with a degree of fidelity that nearly compares to

(B) it possible to have high-definition digital video cameras that can capture material at a degree of fidelity almost like that with

(C) it possible for high-definition digital video cameras to capture material with a degree of fidelity nearly comparable to that of

(D) possible high-definition digital video cameras that can capture material at a degree of fidelity almost like

(E) possible high-definition digital video cameras able to capture material with a degree of fidelity that nearly compares to that with




在B和C当中犹豫了一下，还是选了B。我想问一下关于C的一个问题，如果选C的话，原文没划线的那部分“ to project it digitally in theaters with no resulting loss of image quality”这个“it”跟前面联系起来的话，不就变成了“made it possible for high-definition digital video cameras to protect it digitally in theaters...”了么，感觉后面这个“it”在这儿不对啊。求NN指正。

kiwifoodtown

个人觉得it这里没什么大问题，指代material。真正的问题是 C选项的几个to的并列错误会混乱句意。

rylstar01

(B) it possible to have high-definition digital video cameras that can capture material at a degree of fidelity almost like that with

(C) it possible for high-definition digital video cameras to capture material with a degree of fidelity nearly comparable to that of

个人觉得是C。说下我自己的思路吧。首先读完全句的时候，出题者要表达的意图为：最近的成就使H-D( high-definition digital video) 1）捕抓的能力2）投影能力成为了可能。也就是说出题者将句子1）和2）整合为一个句子的时候，使用了and，即非划线部分的to project，其的逻辑主语应该为H-D，从语法的角度看的话，B和C，我觉得都没有问题，但是从逻辑主语的角度看的话，B的逻辑主语为Recent breakthrough；C的逻辑主语为H-D。

zikuier

(B) it possible to have high-definition digital video cameras that can capture material at a degree of fidelity almost like that with

(C) it possible for high-definition digital video cameras to capture material with a degree of fidelity nearly comparable to that of

个人觉得是C。说下我自己的思路吧。首先读完全句的时候，出题者要表达的意图为：最近的成就使H-D( high-definition digital video) 1）捕抓的能力2）投影能力成为了可能。也就是说出题者将句子1）和2）整合为一个句子的时候，使用了and，即非划线部分的to project，其的逻辑主语应该为H-D，从语法的角度看的话，B和C，我觉得都没有问题，但是从逻辑主语的角度看的话，B的逻辑主语为Recent breakthrough；C的逻辑主语为H-D。

-- by 会员 rylstar01 (2013/3/19 10:00:52)

就是说对 to capture和 to project 来说，动作发出者应该是 H-D才对是吧？

zikuier

(B) it possible to have high-definition digital video cameras that can capture material at a degree of fidelity almost like that with

(C) it possible for high-definition digital video cameras to capture material with a degree of fidelity nearly comparable to that of

个人觉得是C。说下我自己的思路吧。首先读完全句的时候，出题者要表达的意图为：最近的成就使H-D( high-definition digital video) 1）捕抓的能力2）投影能力成为了可能。也就是说出题者将句子1）和2）整合为一个句子的时候，使用了and，即非划线部分的to project，其的逻辑主语应该为H-D，从语法的角度看的话，B和C，我觉得都没有问题，但是从逻辑主语的角度看的话，B的逻辑主语为Recent breakthrough；C的逻辑主语为H-D。

-- by 会员 rylstar01 (2013/3/19 10:00:52)

就是说对 to capture和 to project 来说，动作发出者应该是 H-D才对是吧？

rylstar01

不好意思，没有补上你说的那句话。
嗯，是的。因为两个动作都是H-D所发出来的，如果组合在一块的话，需要平行：）
很多时候，一般形式上平行就对了，但是有些题的话，尤其是两个选项语法都正确的情况下，就需要考虑逻辑了。
纯个人观点。还请斧正

kiwifoodtown

LS，不好意思，这题我不能理解你的解释，不认为这些to 的位置会很混乱吗？

kiwifoodtown

OK,想了一下，明白为什么是C了。

kwok1123

it 指代material，to capture和to project结构平行，动作上的递进关系，camera先capture material，再将其project。
我认为B选项语法不正确，如果第一个to的发出者是technology，第二个it没有指代。to have也很奇怪。B就像C和D选项的综合体。