[原创]With在og中的用法总结

ring_cheng

我想：with的独立主格结构除了可以修饰主语，起解释说明作用外，还可以表示伴随，既是“伴随”，那么动作理应紧跟在伴随对象后，起补充说明作用。翻译过来就是seen monkeys sleeping on the branches and seen their arms and legs hanging...

请讨论。

laure

GMAT 的SC最终考的还是一个逻辑。

在og113和og985中，with 虽然处在句末，从语法上可能指代两个对象，但是从逻辑上，很容易判断其逻辑主语，免于指代混乱的状况。

The rule is a means to an end, but not a set of rigid intructment which should be used without the our own rationale.

欢迎指正：）

999DSCD

好贴！

leiby1019

牛贴啊 受益良多

steveyangxt

hao

carlito

果然就是大牛啊，不一般啊！牛！！

princeshao

我顶！！！

specialcognac

以下是引用jerrold0023在2005-6-12 16:43:00的发言：

感谢12楼和15楼的总结。我在大全中试了试，发现几乎所有题都符合二位的观点。只有下面两个题有例外。正像大家说的，独立的with介词短语在句末绝对是不太好的选项，但不一定是必错项。

OG113.   Visitors to the park have often looked up into the leafy canopy and seen monkeys sleeping on the branches, with arms and legs hanging like socks on a clothesline.

大全985  Those who have visited the Grand Canyon have typically been able to see layers of sediment in the gaping canyon,
                with different colors marking the passage of time like the rings in a tree trunk.

个人认为jerrryguan和davidcooper说的应该是正确的，兄弟的这两个例子并不是例外，因为这两个with在这里都是独立主格，而不是介词短语；with介词短语放在句末不是好选项，应该这个可以作为GMAT的一条判断原则吧

isesameql

记号，值得慢慢研究

补充一个例子

The traditional view supposes that the upper mantle of the earth behaves as a liquid when it is subjected to small forces for long periods and that differences in temperature under oceans and continents are sufficient to produce convection in the mantle of the earth with rising convection currents under the mid-ocean ridges and sinking currents under the continents.

当 主＋谓＋宾＋with＋分词

我认为的优先级

1.谓语的固定搭配

2.状语

3.宾语修饰语（这种应该很少）

llxx1985cn

弱问一下：with引导独立主格和with引导介词短语在形式上有什么区别？