大全108 D选项的理解

bigp

108.An array of tax incentives has led to a boom in the construction of new office
buildings; so abundant has capital been for commercial real estate that investors
regularly scour the country for areas in which to build.
(A) so abundant has capital been for commercial real estate that
(B) capital has been so abundant for commercial real estate, so that
(C) the abundance of capital for commercial real estate has been such,
(D) such has the abundance of capital been for commercial real estate that
(E) such has been an abundance of capital for commercial real estate,

对D选项的理解是否应该是：

原句还原为正常语序是否应该为：

the abundance of capital has been such for commercial real estate that

从而根据句意，该句不能准确表达原文句意，因而排除。

谢谢！

joe11

Such + n. + that ....

such abandance of the capital has been that ... 还差不多

bigp

我之所以那样翻译，是因为感觉D选项是一个语法上讲，正确的倒装句。如果不考虑原文的句意，该句可以理解为我所还原的句子的倒装：有下例为证：

Such has the growth been in these tours that Húsavík town is now well
known as The Whale Watching Capital of Europe.

之所以贴这个帖子，就是想考证该句是否真的为语法正确。谢谢。

loveguitar

哦，好像一般so＋adj优于such＋n吧，特别是abandance这个单词很古怪的，应该是比较抽象的名词，所以用 so abundant比较好

mutegirl

以下是引用bigp在2004-11-20 4:19:00的

对D选项的理解是否应该是：

原句还原为正常语序是否应该为：

the abundance of capital has been such for commercial real estate that

从而根据句意，该句不能准确表达原文句意，因而排除。

谢谢！

这个还原是错的吧，has been such ，没有这种说法啊

singdeath

以下是引用bigp在2004-11-20 9:47:00的发言：

我之所以那样翻译，是因为感觉D选项是一个语法上讲，正确的倒装句。如果不考虑原文的句意，该句可以理解为我所还原的句子的倒装：有下例为证：

Such
                has
                the growth been in these tours that Húsavík town is now well
known as The Whale Watching Capital of Europe.

之所以贴这个帖子，就是想考证该句是否真的为语法正确。谢谢。

我研究了N久，终于搞清楚such that 做强调和做举例在倒装情况下怎么区分怎么应用了，下面是我的一点笔记，可能罗嗦，请耐心看，希望对大家有帮助。

                
                

Such
                    has
                    the
growth been in these tours that Húsavík town is now well known as The Whale
Watching Capital of Europe.

                

此句不同于本题。上句中只有growth一个主语，没有形容词比如fast，做表语。还原后成：The growth has been such that，而不是the growth has been so fast that.原句还原后，such做代词，指代that从句的一个situation，说明growth的程度。

                

比较这两个出自朗文的例子：

                

His courage was
such that

                

His courage was so
great that

                

如果把这两个句子倒装：

                

Such was his
courage that (类似上面的例子原句)

                

So great was his
courage that (类似本题原句)

                

 

                

如果象D选项一样改成such，变成：such greatness was his courage that

                

还原：
                    His courage was such greatness that…

                

这是举例形式，而非强调形式，courage就变成greatness的一种，that的从句就成了courage与greatness之间的关系，即courage怎么属于greatness了。

                

至少应该是：The greatness
of his courage was such
that, 这才是强调形式

                

倒装后成：Such the
greatness of his courage
was that

                

注意such后面的名词在做举例和做强调的情况下的变化

                

 

                

说回到原题：A选项肯定是没有问题。但是D选项的倒装呢？

                

就象上面的例句
                    Such the greatness of his courage was that,

                

把D还原：The abundance of…. has been such that, 主要结构没有问题，问题在于abundance的修饰成分。

                

原句应该是The abundance of
the capital for commercial real estate has been such that,

                

倒装应该是Such the abundance
of the capital for commercial real estate has been that

                

有点头重脚轻，可以调整为：
                    Such the abundance of the
capital has been for
commercial real estate that

                

但是如果倒装成
                    Such the abundance has been the capital for commercial real estate that 就成了举例形式

                

仔细体会黑体部分的区别。

                

 

                

 

                

关于such做代词
                    （朗文）：that thing, fact, or action:

                

e.g. We had
predicted a Welsh victory, and such indeed was the result. (such代 a Welsh victory)

                

 

                

再多个朗文的倒装例子：

                

原句：The force of the explosion
was such that it blew out all the windows.

                

倒装：Such the force of the
explosion was that it blew out all the windows.

                

            Such strength of the force of the
explosion was that

                

           (The
strength of the force of the explosion was such that)

                

           
Such strength was the force of the explosion that 就是错的，是举例而非强调，表明force是strength的一种

                

           
So strong was the force of the explosion that it blew out all the
windows.

                

           (The
force of the explosion was so strong that it blew out all the windows.)

                

 

                

顺便，这个句子也是对的：The
explosion blew out all the windows, such was its force.

                    

个人觉得这也是个倒装，
                        Its force was such (that) the explosion blew
out all the windows.

                    

 

                    
                

这些都是我个人的看法和体会，肯定有漏洞的地方，还请指正！

                
            

我爱周末

有点头重脚轻，可以调整为：
            Such the abundance of the capital has been for commercial real estate that

但是如果倒装成
            Such the abundance has been the capital for commercial real estate that 就成了举例形式

singdeath, 谢谢帮我们提供了好的帖子， 我终于明白了为什么大全中对D 项的解释是Choices C, D, and E alter somewhat the intended meaning of the sentence; because of its position in these statements, such functions to mean “of a kind” rather than to intensify abundant.
                        

但是我对bigp举的上述的两个例子有疑问， 我认为

第一句： Such the abundance of the capital has been for commercial real estate that 应该举例。所以错误了。

第二句：Such the abundance has been the capital for commercial real estate that  应该为强调，等于A 选。  

Bigp 好象弄反了。