不知怎么回事，居然对OG102发晕了

rt316

在G语法中being一般是用来做现在分词强调动作同时发生的，1911年和1972年的事不可能同时发生，OG86的例子也一样。

zhoushao

谢谢rtGG和colacat

zhoushao

我今天在看这题，关于being又有些新的想法

若是把being staged理解为被动语态得进行时得话，就表示持续性得动作，但是stage表示“上演，举行”所以不能说1911年这一年永远都在上演举行这个状态，应该表示一个过去完成的状态。不知这样理解对不对？

薰衣紫草

performance being staged by...就是一个啰唆结构. 因为performance staged by...完全可以表达一个被动语态.

zhoushao

以下是引用薰衣紫草在2005-3-24 7:39:00的发言：

performance being staged by...就是一个啰唆结构. 因为performance staged by...完全可以表达一个被动语态.

但是被动语态和被动语态得进行时表达得意思可是不一样得哦

ps:OG上也说得是"Cuse the particicple being inappropriately"而不是wordy

peajack

讨论的真好呀。

violetyang83

102. Except for a concert performance that the composer himself staged in 1911, Scott Joplin's ragtime opera Treemonisha was not produced until 1972, sixty-one years after its completion.

(A)          Except for a concert performance that the composer himself staged

(B)          Except for a concert performance with the composer himself staging it

(C)          Besides a concert performance being staged by the composer himself

(D)          Excepting a concert performance that the composer himself staged

(E)   With the exception of a concert performance with the staging done by the composer himself

B选项为什么错呢？ ETS的解释感觉很牵强啊。而且这样的用法感觉有很多呢？

我觉得it在这里是no referent。 对吗？

carypig

我觉得是多了个"it"

foreinter

Longman里的解释：

stage [transitive]
1
to organize a public event
stage a strike/demonstration/sit-in

etc １.Activists staged a protest outside the parliament.

２.exhibitions staged in Paris

３.The candidates' public appearances were carefully staged (=not natural) .

特别是例句2，就是用的过去分词修饰的exhibitions,应该和本题差不多，

being +过去分词是不是表示“正在被进行的”意思，请指正

livary

可能有时候按语法来讲being是没有错误的,不过按照ETS的思路来讲being绝大多数都是错误的(在划线部分),只有一种情况,就是介词+being,才有可能正确,这是ETS思路,可是不知道为什么??