【在线等】一题求解

catherinesjy

语法弱弱，prep一题求解

In her 26 years in the forests of Gombe, Jane Goodall collected data that proved that chimpanzees exhibit the kind of curiosity so that new patterns of behavior and expression can be passed on from each one to others by imitating and practicing
A. exhibit the kind of curiosity so that new patterns of behavior and expression can be passed on from each one to others by imitating and practicing
B. will exhibit the kind of curiosity so that new patterns of behavior and expression can be passed on from one to another by imitating and practicing
C. will exhibit the kind of curiosity so that new patterns of behavior and expression can be passed on from one to another by imitation and practice
D. exhibit the kind of curiosity by which new patterns of behavior and expression can be passed on from one to another by imitation and practice
E. exhibit the kind of curiosity where new patterns of behavior and expression are passed on to others by imitation and practice


D。
网上有说因为proved所以排除两个带will的选项，但是想请问下是因为prove本身不可以接将来时还是说prove这个词用了过去式，所以后面will要用的话改would，如果因为过去式的话，为什么exhibit又没用过去式呢？
另外，其他还有什么选出正确答案的判断细节？

shangchangle

从句意而言，即使是prove，也不能用will，因为这是data，是一个调查得到的事实，用一般现在时即可；之所以exhibit不是过去式，也是因为这是调查得到的事实，或者说是黑猩猩的习惯，都应该用一般现在时~

shangchangle

A项的“each one to others”是硬伤，但是不清楚D/E的“by which”和“where”的取舍~~求解答

catherinesjy

原来如此，从data这里来理解就好理解多了。谢了！

catherinesjy

A项的“each one to others”是硬伤，但是不清楚D/E的“by which”和“where”的取舍~~求解答

-- by 会员 shangchangle (2012/1/23 20:49:22)

话说我是从are 和 can be那里区分的，感觉can be更像陈述一个结论事实。。。


同求解by which 和where？

shangchangle

没注意到。。。眼拙了。。。的确“can be" 比 "are"合适的多！谢了~

babybearmm

Manhattan SC上面讲过, where只能指表具体地点。
而抽象的“地点”——例如situation/circumstances/instances/...这些只能用preposition (in/of/...看情况）+ which。这道题"curiosity"肯定不能用where，必须用by which

另外，这里需要用one another，根据句意。（我是用时态+one another来排除锁定答案的）
否则that从句里面就是"Ch（大猩猩） ..... others"，似乎others是和大猩猩独立的。
Analagy:
Some people believe that.... Others hold that ....
用"others"肯定就是对立于前面的名词

A项的“each one to others”是硬伤，但是不清楚D/E的“by which”和“where”的取舍~~求解答

-- by 会员 shangchangle (2012/1/23 20:49:22)

babybearmm

我个人觉得，can be和are都可以，意思有点区别
are passed by 就是陈述事实
can be passed by 强调能够
带进原句应该都可以。欢迎讨论

话说我是从are 和 can be那里区分的，感觉can be更像陈述一个结论事实。。。


同求解by which 和where？

-- by 会员 catherinesjy (2012/1/23 20:52:14)

shangchangle

Manhattan SC上面讲过, where只能指表具体地点。
而抽象的“地点”——例如situation/circumstances/instances/...这些只能用preposition (in/of/...看情况）+ which。这道题"curiosity"肯定不能用where，必须用by which

另外，这里需要用one another，根据句意。（我是用时态+one another来排除锁定答案的）
否则that从句里面就是"Ch（大猩猩） ..... others"，似乎others是和大猩猩独立的。
Analagy:
Some people believe that.... Others hold that ....
用"others"肯定就是对立于前面的名词

A项的“each one to others”是硬伤，但是不清楚D/E的“by which”和“where”的取舍~~求解答

-- by 会员 shangchangle (2012/1/23 20:49:22)

-- by 会员 babybearmm (2012/1/24 19:06:41)

MM正解！找到了= =。。。The pronoun where can be used to modify a noun place, such as area, site, country or Nevada. Where cannot modify a “metaphorical” place, such as condition, situation, case, circumstances, or arrangement. In this case, use in which rather than where.