og 235 help

风过疏竹

C：Miiller's career began with the unpromising apprenticeship of being

Choice C corrects this error but produces an unidiomatic construction by using apprenticeship of being instead of apprenticeship as.

OG的解释里面，of being 的说法是不符合语言习惯的，这是排除它的主要原因。而且这个句子的主语是career所以才用as.这也是排除的一个方法。

而我的问题恰好就是OF BEING和as

我们常常说，being a student, I should study hard.

Being 和as的用法是不是一样的呀？实际上是没有Of being这个说法呀。

谢谢

[此贴子已经被作者于2005-10-15 20:32:09编辑过]

风过疏竹

up

arrow9999

以下是引用风过疏竹在2005-10-15 12:57:00的发言：

C：Miiller's career began with the unpromising apprenticeship of being

Choice C corrects this error but produces an unidiomatic construction by using apprenticeship of being instead of apprenticeship as.

OG的解释里面，of being 的说法是不符合语言习惯的，这是排除它的主要原因。而且这个句子的主语是career所以才用as.这也是排除的一个方法。

而我的问题恰好就是OF BEING和as

我们常常说，being a student, I should study hard.

Being 和as的用法是不是一样的呀？实际上是没有Of being这个说法呀。

谢谢

帮21楼UP

z520m

of being是不定式用法，就是说is的意思，可是这里应该用as比较妥当，就像og里的什么什么as a result和being a result的区别一样，在逻辑上和语法上，og严格区分as 和being的表达。我不知道我这样有没有表达清楚，在很多情况下，只有对等的A is B,而不对等的可以A as B.

mmfoolish

问题：Miiler's career 和 the career of Miiler 有什么区别？？？

goodwish

以下是引用mmfoolish在2005-11-20 20:36:00的发言：

问题：Miiler's career 和 the career of Miiler 有什么区别？？？

\Same question;

tdyg

以下是引用goodwish在2006-1-6 0:02:00的发言：

问题：Miiler's career 和 the career of Miiler 有什么区别？？？

\Same question;

OG没有说the career of Miiler 有什么错。之所以把它放在错误选项里，大概是觉得这也是一个不妥的选项。

如果说它有什么不妥，我认为那就是wordy，没有Miiler's career 那么干脆、直截了当。何必饶来饶去？直接说Miiler's career 不就行了吗？

hyte

以下是引用风过疏竹在2005-10-15 12:57:00的发言：

C：Miiller's career began with the unpromising apprenticeship of being

Choice C corrects this error but produces an unidiomatic construction by using apprenticeship of being instead of apprenticeship as.

OG的解释里面，of being 的说法是不符合语言习惯的，这是排除它的主要原因。而且这个句子的主语是career所以才用as.这也是排除的一个方法。

而我的问题恰好就是OF BEING和as

我们常常说，being a student, I should study hard.

Being 和as的用法是不是一样的呀？实际上是没有Of being这个说法呀。

谢谢

ETS不喜歡being結構～您的例句最好改成: To be a student, I should study hard.

juliet01192000

235. Spanning more than fifty years, Friedrich Miller began his career in an unpromising apprenticeship as a Sanskrit scholar and culminated in virtually every honor that European governments and learned societies could bestow.

(A) Miller began his career in an unpromising apprenticeship as

(B) Miller’s career began in an unpromising apprenticeship as

(C) Miller’s career began with the unpromising apprenticeship of being

(D) Miller had begun his career with the unpromising apprenticeship of being（B）

(E) the career of Miller has begun with an unpromising apprenticeship of

ans:B

实在是不明白！

1 我认为Friedrich这个人发出 Spanning 和culminated这两个动作是符合逻辑的，为什么og和xdjm们说不符合？

2 在作题时，我一看到 Miller’s career 和as a Sanskrit scholar 对应我就先把B给排除了！想问Miller’s career 是没有生命的，他怎么能做a Sanskrit scholar（学者） ？？？

看了大家的讨论还是不明白。

盼解答，谢谢！：）

juliet01192000

up!