ChaseDream
搜索
返回列表 发新帖
楼主: yuanxun59
打印 上一主题 下一主题

求NN解答OG12 SC33中错误选项的错误原因~~ 已经彻底混乱了~~

[复制链接]
11#
发表于 2012-3-15 19:54:10 | 只看该作者
真心不明白E的Due to followed by with the result is redundant and unnecessarily wordy.

意思是due to不能再跟with了吗,我当时看见due to逗号with就把with当独立主格了
12#
发表于 2012-3-29 16:58:32 | 只看该作者
真心不明白E的Due to followed by with the result is redundant and unnecessarily wordy.

意思是due to不能再跟with了吗,我当时看见due to逗号with就把with当独立主格了
-- by 会员 潇湘妃子zwhj (2012/3/15 19:54:10)

due to 本来就与result from 同义,本来可以用because一句话表明逻辑关系的话说:由于……,它是……的结果  就wordy了
13#
发表于 2012-3-29 17:23:56 | 只看该作者
due to 代表caused by,而且一般gmat没有以due to 为答案的正选
14#
发表于 2012-6-27 23:59:30 | 只看该作者
此题关于D的解释我研究了很久,终于得出较为确切的答案,分享给大家:
33. Because an oversupply of computer chips has sent prices plunging, the manufacturer has announced that it will cut production by closing its factories for two days a month.
(A) Because an oversupply of computer chips has sent prices plunging,(正解)
... ...
(D) Due to plunging computer chip prices from an oversupply,
... ..

Agreement; Rhetorical construction
This sentence describes a causal sequence of events: The oversupply of chips caused prices to plunge, which in turn caused the manufacturer to announce factory closings to cut production. The clearest, most efficient way to express this sequence is to present the events in chronological order, as they occurred.
... ...
D This backward description of the events behind the announcement of factory closingsis confusing and awkward.

首先,应该要注意OG对这题开头的宏观解释提到,"The clearest, most efficient way to express this sequence is to present the events in chronological order, as they occurred."
也就是说,本题所强调的是,在causal sequence里,应该尽可能按照事物发展的顺序来表述。而本题所提到任何先后顺序指的都是“表述顺序”,而非我们容易误解的“逻辑顺序”。

接着具体分析D选项的解释。如颜色标注,将这句话分为了两部分来解释。

"This backward description of the events"  

oversupply-->price plunge ( -->cut production ) 这是事情发展的顺序
而D是price plunge-->oversupply ( -->cut production ) 就叫backward description
而此处"the events"很明显是指"oversupply、price plunge", these 2 events

"behind the announcement of factory closings"
behind很多人又会不理解,不是发生在announcement之前么
这是关于时态的理解,我来造一个句,大家就明白了:
D选项的句子是Due to B, one has done A. →Due to raining, she has brought an umbrella.(因为外面将会下雨,她事先带了一把伞)→B发生在A之后,但是B仍然是A的原因
这与Due to B, one did A. →Due to raining, she brought an umbrella.(因为外面正在下雨,她于是带了一把伞)→B发生在A之前,B也是A的原因
两者是有明显不同的

这也就是为什么D说,the backward description of these 2 events behind the announcement is confusing and awkward 的原因了
Again, it's obviously that the real sequence here should be “oversupply-->price plunge-->cut production”.
15#
发表于 2012-6-28 00:15:07 | 只看该作者
当然了,大家可以看出,在这样的句子里使用Due to是很awkward的 一般我们不这样说

Due to raining, she has brought an umbrella.
Due to raining, she brought an umbrella.
这两句句子,仅仅作为对时态理解的举例,不能过于当真~
16#
发表于 2012-6-28 00:52:46 | 只看该作者
C选项的which,按照Gmat的语法只能向前跳跃指代名词prices,因此price到底是先来自于oversupply,还是先被sent plugging,这里光看时态是分不清楚的(过去时和完成时都发生在现在以前),所以OG说时间顺序confusing;D选项,due to在Gmat里99%是错误选项标志,理由是due to只能跟名词不能跟句子,但是当我们往往要表达一个原因的时候,这个原因往往是一句句子,而不是某一个东西(某一个名词)。

就拿这个题举例,生厂商降低产量的原因是芯片价格供给过多而被抬高,这整个一件事情是原因,所以用becuase+句子的表达最恰当。如果换成due to,就算加了语法上讲得通的形容词或者定语从句,这个原因的重心依然是某一个词,而不是某一个现象。D选项中,这个中心词就是prices。生产商不是因为“价格”而削减产量,而是因为“价格被抬高”而削减产量。你如果能够明白这两者的区别,你就能够明白为什么gmat中due to结构基本上都是错误的。
17#
发表于 2012-6-28 08:45:07 | 只看该作者
我主要集中于OG D选项的解释内容很难懂

LS对于due to的错误原因的本质,我觉得分析得很到位~ 赞一个!
18#
发表于 2012-6-28 09:18:50 | 只看该作者
看到猴哥的链接我也来说下看法,非常赞同#16楼的观点。
其实这题就是考逻辑,读懂句意之后,看选项开头就能选了,只能是A.

提炼下句意:
Because an oversupply has sent price plunging, ...that  it (the manufacturer) will cut production...

oversupply 完美对应cut production  (i.e. cut supply)
oversupply造成了不利的后果(price plunging),所以导致cut production

所以因果关系必须用句子体现:Because an oversupply has sent price plunging
19#
发表于 2012-6-28 11:09:53 | 只看该作者
我主要集中于OG D选项的解释内容很难懂

LS对于due to的错误原因的本质,我觉得分析得很到位~ 赞一个!
-- by 会员 铁板神猴 (2012/6/28 8:45:07)



荣幸之至。
20#
发表于 2012-9-25 10:32:10 | 只看该作者
choice C: computer chip prices have been sent
plunging(现在完成时-先)
, which resulted from an oversupply(过去式-后)
不合逻辑

个人看法!
您需要登录后才可以回帖 登录 | 立即注册

Mark一下! 看一下! 顶楼主! 感谢分享! 快速回复:

IESE MBA
近期活动

正在浏览此版块的会员 ()

手机版|ChaseDream|GMT+8, 2024-12-28 12:52
京公网安备11010202008513号 京ICP证101109号 京ICP备12012021号

ChaseDream 论坛

© 2003-2023 ChaseDream.com. All Rights Reserved.

返回顶部