谁能回答下呢！谢谢~希望版主能回答下~

jameshzd

Only seven people this century have been killed by the great white shark, the man-eater of the movies—less than those killed by bee stings.

A.movies—less than those

B.movies—fewer than have been

C.movies, which is less than those

D.movies, a number lower than the people(B)

E.movies, fewer than the ones

我有三个问题啊，第一：我知道如果主语是特指的情况下，比较主语时从句的that/ those 是必须要的，那么seven people 不算特指吗？所以我觉得those 不能省略啊。 第二：the ones 是不是不能做指代people啊？ones 是怎么用啊？第三：the man-eater of the movies --在句子是充当什么成分呢？我不明白它的作用。。。谢谢回答啊！

vinbobo

Only seven people this century have been killed by the great white shark, the man-eater of the movies—less than those killed by bee stings.

A.movies—less than those

B.movies—fewer than have been

C.movies, which is less than those

D.movies, a number lower than the people(B)

E.movies, fewer than the ones

我有三个问题啊，第一：我知道如果主语是特指的情况下，比较主语时从句的that/ those 是必须要的，那么seven people 不算特指吗？所以我觉得those 不能省略啊。 第二：the ones 是不是不能做指代people啊？ones 是怎么用啊？第三：the man-eater of the movies --在句子是充当什么成分呢？我不明白它的作用。。。谢谢回答啊！

-- by 会员 jameshzd (2011/7/28 20:03:02)

1 这里确实是补出来比较好，但是如果说前后都是people，这个问题不算太大
2 有one 和 ones 的话前面要出现总类别，必须是某个群体其中的一个
3  the man-eater of the movies,这是 the great white shark的同位语

jameshzd

Only seven people this century have been killed by the great white shark, the man-eater of the movies—less than those killed by bee stings.

A.movies—less than those

B.movies—fewer than have been

C.movies, which is less than those

D.movies, a number lower than the people(B)

E.movies, fewer than the ones

我有三个问题啊，第一：我知道如果主语是特指的情况下，比较主语时从句的that/ those 是必须要的，那么seven people 不算特指吗？所以我觉得those 不能省略啊。 第二：the ones 是不是不能做指代people啊？ones 是怎么用啊？第三：the man-eater of the movies --在句子是充当什么成分呢？我不明白它的作用。。。谢谢回答啊！

-- by 会员 jameshzd (2011/7/28 20:03:02)

1 这里确实是补出来比较好，但是如果说前后都是people，这个问题不算太大
2 有one 和 ones 的话前面要出现总类别，必须是某个群体其中的一个
3  the man-eater of the movies,这是 the great white shark的同位语

-- by 会员 vinbobo (2011/7/28 20:52:54)

谢谢回答哈，我觉得only seven people 这里算不算是特指啊，应该不算吧？不是说前后都是指的people，主语就可以省略，如果前面的people 是特指的话，和后面的people 不一样的话，是应该补出来的。你对ones 的解释我好像有点明白，但又不是很明白，能举个可以用ones 的例子吗？额，我没表达清楚，我是问破折号是什么意思？为什么破折号可以这样用。。

vinbobo

破折号多有3种用法
1 举例
2 对前面某个词的 说明
3 对前面句子的解释说明

这里是第三个

jameshzd

破折号多有3种用法
1 举例
2 对前面某个词的 说明
3 对前面句子的解释说明

这里是第三个

-- by 会员 vinbobo (2011/7/28 21:08:36)

嘿嘿，谢谢well-done！呵呵，嗯。那ones 的举例能帮我讲哈吗？啥时候用ones？

vinbobo

One
One indicates an indefinite copy or a single, indefinite part of a collection.
After walking by the chocolates so many times, Roger finally had to eat ONE.
The particular chocolate was not delineated ahead oftime, In contrast, the personal pronouns
it and they/them indicate definite selection of an entire object or collection.
After walking by the chocolates so many times, Roger finally had to eat THEM.
In this case, Roger ate all the chocolates! Notice that after Roger has selected a chocolate, we
now refer to that particular chocolate using the definite pronoun it.
After walking by the chocolates so many times, Roger finally had to eat ONE.
IT was delicious, but HEcould eat only half of IT.

jameshzd

懂了懂了，one 或是ones 是指代一个群体里面不特定的集合，那么这里用 ones 肯定是错误的了！谢谢！！！！

MarsTOF

如果是those 还能用less 么。。。than 可以做代词成分。。有先例。。 （但实际上据说是一个省略成分来着。。具体忘了。。）

vinbobo

如果是those 还能用less 么。。。than 可以做代词成分。。有先例。。 （但实际上据说是一个省略成分来着。。具体忘了。。）

-- by 会员 MarsTOF (2011/7/28 21:29:43)

用不用those，less都不对吧
你的先例是指？

jameshzd

如果是those 还能用less 么。。。than 可以做代词成分。。有先例。。 （但实际上据说是一个省略成分来着。。具体忘了。。）

-- by 会员 MarsTOF (2011/7/28 21:29:43)

用不用those，less都不对吧
你的先例是指？

-- by 会员 vinbobo (2011/7/28 21:31:30)

先例比如说：Fewer people will enter the labor force in the 1980's than (few people 省略） did in the 1960's and 1970's. 这里可以省略是因为前面的主语不是特指，所以可以省略，我觉得我贴的这道题是一样的，估计 only seven people 没有特指，只是说people 被killed 有几个而已。