来看一道SC 急啊 B为什么错

低调进步

你对介词+which的用法解释得有偏差    我这几天做GWD中出现过正确选项中含 介词+which的    有个印象很深   ， BY  WHICH

其次  你还原的那句话也有误  真正的应该是 $xx  was paid for ......

低调进步

Most of Portugal’s 250,000 university students boycotted classes in a one-day strike to protest a law that requires them to contribute $330 ayear toward the cost of higher education, previously paying $7 per year.

A.year toward the cost of higher education, previously paying $7 per year

B.year toward the cost of higher education, for which was previously paid $7 per year

C.year, compared to the previously $7 per year, toward the cost of higher education

D.year toward the cost of higher education, instead of the $7 per year required previously

E.year as opposed to the $7 per year required previously for the cost of higher education
这道题目为什么B不对？牛人解释，没觉得错啊。。。

-- by 会员 zlljolie (2011/7/15 21:08:13)

选D

A  分词短语被逗号隔开放在句尾，做伴随状语。句子结构是：students boycotted classes...to protest a law that...a year toward the cost of higher education,  previously paying $7 per year.

先看原句，paying做伴随状语伴随主句动作，明显是错的。

B for which介词加which形式，教你一个判断介词加which是否正确的捷径：把which所指代的对象恢复成一个陈述句，the cost of higher education was previously paid 7 USD per year. 不需要加介词对么？
再举个例子：
找一个需要加介词的句子：this is the house which i was born in
this is the house in which i was born
this is the reason which he did so much things for
this is the reason for which he did so much things.

那么，原话是否需要介词for? 而且我目前为止还没见过介词+which在逗号后的正确句子出现在OG里。

所以从逻辑上和GMAC的习惯上，这个for which都说不通。

C 过去分词短语作非限制性修饰成分，这个大结构看似没问题。但这个可以set off by comma的过去分词短语自己，previously修饰的是谁？肯定不是compared,那么这个短语里面已经没有其他词可以被副词修饰了，副词也不可能跳跃修饰到逗号外面去，因此C错。

D instead of...介词短语做补语，对higher cost的补充说明，整个句子在结构上和用词上找不出什么问题。

E, 错的一塌糊涂了，不用我说了吧....

-- by 会员 无敌可爱多 (2011/7/16 3:54:15)

你对介词+which的用法解释得有偏差    我这几天做GWD中出现过正确选项中含 介词+which的    有个印象很深   ， BY  WHICH

其次  你还原的那句话  真正的应该是 $xx  was paid for education吧？

jasminerocks

我也觉得应该选D

情未浓

Most of Portugal’s 250,000 university students boycotted classes in a one-day strike to protest a law that requires them to contribute $330 ayear toward the cost of higher education, previously paying $7 per year.

A.year toward the cost of higher education, previously paying $7 per year

B.year toward the cost of higher education, for which was previously paid $7 per year

C.year, compared to the previously $7 per year, toward the cost of higher education

D.year toward the cost of higher education, instead of the $7 per year required previously

E.year as opposed to the $7 per year required previously for the cost of higher education
这道题目为什么B不对？牛人解释，没觉得错啊。。。

-- by 会员 zlljolie (2011/7/15 21:08:13)

选D

A  分词短语被逗号隔开放在句尾，做伴随状语。句子结构是：students boycotted classes...to protest a law that...a year toward the cost of higher education,  previously paying $7 per year.

先看原句，paying做伴随状语伴随主句动作，明显是错的。

B for which介词加which形式，教你一个判断介词加which是否正确的捷径：把which所指代的对象恢复成一个陈述句，the cost of higher education was previously paid 7 USD per year. 不需要加介词对么？
再举个例子：
找一个需要加介词的句子：this is the house which i was born in
this is the house in which i was born
this is the reason which he did so much things for
this is the reason for which he did so much things.

那么，原话是否需要介词for? 而且我目前为止还没见过介词+which在逗号后的正确句子出现在OG里。

所以从逻辑上和GMAC的习惯上，这个for which都说不通。

C 过去分词短语作非限制性修饰成分，这个大结构看似没问题。但这个可以set off by comma的过去分词短语自己，previously修饰的是谁？肯定不是compared,那么这个短语里面已经没有其他词可以被副词修饰了，副词也不可能跳跃修饰到逗号外面去，因此C错。

D instead of...介词短语做补语，对higher cost的补充说明，整个句子在结构上和用词上找不出什么问题。

E, 错的一塌糊涂了，不用我说了吧....

-- by 会员 无敌可爱多 (2011/7/16 3:54:15)

agree!