OG223 再次深入 such as

aaaaaaaa

223. As business grows more complex, students majoring in specialized areas like those of finance and marketing have been becoming increasingly successful in the job market.

(A)  majoring in specialized areas like those of finance and marketing have been becoming increasingly

(B)  who major in such specialized areas as finance and marketing are becoming more and more

(C)  who majored in specialized areas such as those of finance and marketing are being increas­ingly

(D) who major in specialized areas like those of finance and marketing have been becoming more and more

(E)  having majored in such specialized areas as finance and marketing are being increasingly

fruit such as apple，banana。。。。such  as 前的名词和后面的名词是同一类词，是总体和个体的区别，  但是OG 223 的 area 和 maketing是两个性质的词语，只能说 area of maketing ，能说 fruit of apple 吗？？？

为什么c 中的such as those of finance and marketing  不对？？

rt316

词与词之间的关系在不同场合表现是不同的，在这个句子中area和marketing/finance之间的关系并非如你所说是两个性质的，area指领域，而marketing市场营销/finance金融都是这个领域的(business area)。从这个角度看，C中的those就缺乏合理的指代对象。

irenelj78

such as 与 like 的区别。

我查剑桥词典的时候怎末看到对like的解释是such as???而且还举例：

1.She looks best in bright,vibrant colors,like red and pink.

2.I prefer clothes which are made out of natual materials like cotton and wool.

此题og解释说like makes  a comparison ; such as introduce examples该怎末理解呢？

能举例子说明吗？谢谢！！！

agk99

to aaaaaaa

不選C還有一個理由，就是who majored 的動詞時態與未劃線的"grows"不一致，違背基本文法

to ireanli78

like 要用在比較句型，也就是前後要同類比較，這點你可以在og的91, 267得到印證；至於such as 顧名思義就是舉例，I have many hobbies, such as reading, seeing a movie, and playing the basketball,這裡的reading....絕對和hobbies不同類，充其量只能把reading...視為hobbies 的一種...

個人意見請指教

[此贴子已经被作者于2004-8-13 4:11:25编辑过]

irenelj78

谢谢agk99的回答，：）

恩，我理解你的说法了，其实只要记住这个规则就好，但是偏偏遇到了这么两个例句，

这两个例句怎末解释呢？我觉得也都是举例子，而非比较啊，难道是错句子？

1.She looks best in bright,vibrant colors,like red and pink.

2.I prefer clothes which are made out of natual materials like cotton and wool.

irenelj78

我明白了，分享一下牛人的解释：GMAT中举例从来不用like,都是用such as.---已经成规则了...GMAT语法自成规则,相对比普通语法严格点....如:consider A as B, consider A to be B...在Toefl都是对的,在GMAT中就是错的!只有consider A B是对的---like/such as也同理

zhuzhu1973

being 与becoming有何区别?

zhuzhu1973

up

anyname

being 状态感强，表现状，becoming 动态感强，表变化。比较以下句子：

He is a student.和 He becomes a student.
He is being strong. 和 He is becoming strong.

[此贴子已经被作者于2005-2-14 9:40:37编辑过]

番茄笑了

以下是引用anyname在2005-2-14 9:38:00的发言：

being 状态感强，表现状，becoming 动态感强，表变化。比较以下句子：

He is a student.和 He becomes a student.
He is being strong. 和 He is becoming strong.

说得好！！