求教GWD最新试题4第4题

anol

i vote for c.

in D, what是charge的宾语,charge后面应该跟一个"钱数",for example,3 dollars. 要用也应该用how much才跟准确,如果是price of what another product with the same active ingredient,还有点道理.

应该是c跟准确.

wwwhahchn

支持C，charge sth.(price) for sth.(商品)，插入语不影响that引导限定性定从的使用

D错，of what唯一合理的理解是what表示商品，这样the price of what是一个整体，the drug's maker charges for ... 做定从修饰该整体，语法上讲得通，但是逻辑上有问题：what指代什么？？

1）what指代后面的another product：

这样就产生了wordy的问题，charge for已经表明了price的所属，前面再加一个(the price) of what重复

2）what指代其他的东东（非句中的another product）：

the drug's maker charges for ... 引导的定从的修饰对象是price，而不是what，对what起不了解释说明的作用，所以what显然does not make sense，应该换成其他的具体商品的名称，比如说anaesthetic。

但这样还是意思不好。不妨假设这里的another product是heroin，带入句中，就变成了the price of anaesthetics the drug's maker charges for heroins。到底是“毒品制造商就海洛因而索要的麻醉剂的价格”呢？还是“毒品制造商就海洛因而索要的价格”呢？？显然后者的意思清楚，前者根本就是不知所云

E错，charge sth.(商品) at sth.(price)对，但是charge for sth.(商品) at sth.(price)就不对了，而此题选E的话，正是用了后一种表达。所以这些用法一定不能混淆

综上所述：

本题肯定选C，强烈建议版主把答案改过来！！！

[此贴子已经被作者于2005-8-3 22:46:20编辑过]

likui

支持，答案也不用改了，就是不要再回复帖子了，不要回下去又没完没了地谈论了。

yayijia

以下是可以支持选d的例子,搜一下很多

The timber that was sold by competitive bidding went for something like three times or four times the price of what was sold at the appraised price and went just to the parties that had the checkerboard.

enjoy coming to Thailand but cannot see my self coming to Pattaya again. I am simply sick and tired of having to pay 3-4 times the price of what Thai nationals pay.

Restaurants will often charge between two to five times the price of what a wine merchant may ask for an exceptional vintage.

there is broadband access but at three times the price of what it costs in Dublin.

oldest

hehe,热闹热闹，还是相信存在即合理，D。

stray2000

支持C。

今天做到一道逻辑题目：突然想到可能对这题有帮助

请参考gwd－5－Q29中的选项D

Because of lower advertising costs, stores are able to offer their own brands of cereals at significantly lower prices than those charged for name-brand cereals.

lykuang02

sorry, I don't know how to delete my response.

[此贴子已经被作者于2005-9-25 18:32:59编辑过]

xulijun

c is right,

drug is being sold for three times the price that the drug's maker charges for another poduct with the same active ingredient,

dreamerps

C

sureno1

恩？？？如果选C的话，请告诉我这个结构中的of能够省略么！？？？

this book is three times the length of that one。

请选C的牛牛解答一下？