答关于finance journals 排名及一些publication的情况

zhangc112358

for top 10 schools, a number of A pubs is a minimum requirement, but no guarantee. 非常难讲他们会tenure 什么人, kick out 什么人. 他们基本上会claim they want their APs to do research with large impact in the prfession before they get tenured. 但是什么是large impact research, 非常主观. 无数牛人被top school kicked out. For example, the current RFS executive editor 当年被columbia 开了。WFA past president and RFS past editor wayne ferson没有办法在芝加哥tenure even he had 10+ A publications. 最近的一个例子是martin cremers of yale. he has 10+ As 但是他没有tenure. 所以top school tenure case 很难讲。。。

very nice post!!!


btw, what is the requirement for tenure promotion in top 10 school? Do you think ppl like Joshua Rauh can get tenured at uchicago if he stayed there for another 2 or 3 years?

-- by 会员 kndx5 (2011/3/20 11:43:34)

-- by 会员 xiaotian24 (2011/3/20 11:53:09)

应该是martijn? Martijn Cremers做的是很好，一开始的RFS还是single author，曾经跟我老板谈起过他，Martijn是他几篇文章的coauthor。感觉还是文章的影响问题吧~

xiaotian24

JFQA确实在走下坡路， 而且很多其他journals（比如JFI, RoF) 也在争取做第四。但是目前公认的第四还是JFQA. 大家基本在burn out all top three journals 后， 首选还是JFQA. 也许一些年以后，这种情况会改变， 但目前就是这样。

Can you share about why you think JFQA is 4th for sure? I heard from people that citation for JFQA has been declining for these years and make it less and less attractive.Thanks.

-- by 会员 Oliver19000 (2011/3/23 19:53:54)

xiaotian24

JCM是哪家杂志？

how about JCM

-- by 会员 fzxc613 (2011/3/24 4:18:40)

finance2012

应该算

journal of Financial Market 也算b+吧

-- by 会员 龙旋九天 (2011/3/20 11:05:54)

zilong728

nice analysis. it's very promising and give me a approximate idea about the life of the APs  and the competition is still keen even you are graduated from phd. whatever, life is a continunous process of competition for us, when you chose the phd style life, you can never turn back forever. one word from my mother, don't make easy decision. once you decided, finished the work by yourself never turn back

hbsmeng

楼主学长我想确认下 top3是不是指的Journal of Financial Economics，Journal of Finance，The Review of Financial Studies谢谢

独孤剑圣

楼主据说是老师，很久没来了。


我可以回答你，就是这三篇。

楼主学长我想确认下 top3是不是指的Journal of Financial Economics，Journal of Finance，The Review of Financial Studies谢谢

-- by 会员 hbsmeng (2011/8/12 0:03:08)

hbsmeng

谢谢剑圣学长  我一直都告诉别人这些杂志很好 不过我想确认下
理论上在金融杂志上发文   第一作者
申请phd finance  会不会很大几率

iiyaya_sun

谢谢剑圣学长  我一直都告诉别人这些杂志很好 不过我想确认下
理论上在金融杂志上发文   第一作者
申请phd finance  会不会很大几率

-- by 会员 hbsmeng (2011/8/12 13:21:31)

基本没有可能。如果是一作发表的话，那不用读phd，直接进top100或相当档次的学校做faculty了。

hbsmeng

我也知道很困难  我是说如果发表了申请博士会有困难吗