一道大全的比较题，求助求助求助 最近问的问题都不见有人回答 呜呜

mofell

the key:A
950.A private house in New York City is a building owned by an individual or individuals having less than eight units and no commercial space.
(A) a building owned by an individual or individuals having less than eight units and no commercial space
(B) one that an individual or individuals own with fewer than eight units and no commercial space
(C) a building with fewer than eight units, no commercial space, and is owned by an individual or individuals
(D) one that has fewer than eight units, no commercial space and it is owned by an individual or individuals
(E) one that has fewer than eight units, is owned by an individual or individuals, and has no commercial space


搜了以前的帖子也没看到关于有解答的
不是说fewer只能形容人 其余都less吗
我猜测的错误原因：

A 是having 的修饰了 an individual or individuals
B 是 with fewer than eight units  也修饰了  an individual or individuals
D it 和one 不能混用
是这样吗？

还有 C为什么错 是不是and is 的is 必须省略

Sakana☆

我随便说说…就当做讨论讨论好了
B.    with fewer than eight units and no commercial space就近修饰引起歧义。书面语中ONE作代词是很傻的事情，尽量不用。
C.    书面语中尽量不用one做指代
       a building with fewer than eight units, no commercial space最好用and连接，避免造成后面3个并列的歧义。
       后面的and理论上是A private house is ...and is.理论上虽然is可以省略，但是这句话的意思是解释privatehouse是什么，后面的is  is owned by an individual or individuals应该是修饰后面的通常的解释而不是前面的一个“private house”。如果修饰private house就改变了原句重心。
D.   one和it导致指代不清
E.    one还是尽量不用。而且这个么- -Has的两个不并列太囧了……

yanxihua00

我觉得凭语感可以直接选出A，D和E选项我同意2楼的，C选项我觉得是a house is a building with ,...... and is owned......不是平行结构，所以排除