GWD3-41

evelyn205205

The market for recycled commodities like aluminum and other metals remain strong despite economic changes in the recycling industry.

1. commodities like aluminum and other metals remain
   
2. commodities like those of aluminum and other metals are remaining
   
3. commodities such as aluminum and other metals remains
   
4. commodities, such as aluminum and other metals, remain
   
5. commodities, like the commodities of aluminum and other metals, remains
   
   ANSWER: E
   我选的是C.
   为什么aluminum and other metals不能指代recycled commodities呢？
   还请各位牛牛指教！
   

sotonfei

从意思上讲，aluminum and other metals 不能等同于commodities这个概念吧，我觉得应该算作commodities的原材料(特征)，所以是the commodities of...，C选项的意思把commodities的原材料直接算作commodities的一种了。再举个例子：如果说...metals such as aluminum and steel 应该就对了, a and s 是 metal 的一种。不知道这样解释是否说得通？

evelyn205205

所以做语法题还是需要逻辑思维的说

aeoluseros

其实答案是C……
E is evidently wrong.我们铝罐、金属罐不是经常拿去当recycled commodities吗，怎么会不能成为商品呢。

evelyn205205

其实答案是C……
E is evidently wrong.我们铝罐、金属罐不是经常拿去当recycled commodities吗，怎么会不能成为商品呢。

-- by 会员 aeoluseros (2011/2/4 19:39:40)

你都说是铝管，铁罐了，不是铝和其他金属。recycled commodities不是要和由铝或其他金属制成的commodities相对应嘛

sotonfei

额...我又有点晕了...这两天看到OG和PREP笔记里都说原则上like不用来举例，举例一般用such as...又在论坛上搜了一下发现这道题以前很多人讨论过。LZ请参考 http://forum.chasedream.com/GMAT_SC/thread-56345-1-1.html， 最后好像倾向于C比较符合GMAT的考试思路，可能答案给的有问题。也谢谢版主提醒。

evelyn205205

谢谢你的提醒，原来讨论下来是选C啊，GWD的答案真可爱啊