急问 wl是否可以再提交一些补充材料

pp1219

被两所学校（M7)wl了 两所学校都说了不鼓励提交补充材料  是为了什么公平起见

可是本人申请的时候手中握有很多dream school的校友资源硬是没用他们的推荐信  觉得不是直接上下级关系  现在想起他们来了 希望他们帮忙 有三个人愿意帮忙

一个是本科的教授 dream school原来的professor 后来因为家庭原因去了我本科所在学校 老美 PHD毕业 楼主本科也不是水货 专业是#1 undergraduate program in the US

一个还是本科教授 知名PE的合伙人 老美 MBA+PHD毕业 不是特别熟 上过课 但对我印象深刻 我是当年本科生中唯一一个出钱给PE的学生

一个是商业伙伴 F500前20大中华区副总裁 中国人 MBA毕业 祖父在位时对这家公司入住中国放宽了政策的限制 提供了便利条件 所以他们很愿意帮这个忙

请问如果他们三个分别提交了推荐信会不会对我的wl产生负面影响，我觉得我现在have nothing to lose，死马当活马医了，这种想法是否正确呢？Jon，作为很有经验的咨询师，有建议吗？

之所以急问是因为推荐信他们基本已经准备好了，准备发了，发晚了，我直接收到ding了，就白求人了不是......

didai1314

我觉得3封信也太夸张了 可能会烦到他们
如果你是GPA弱点那就教授信 如果是工作方面弱点你就商业伙伴信
我觉得给一个足够了

JonFrank

Hey there!  If the school has specifically told you NOT to submit anything, then of course you need to do what they request.  If you do not follow their directions, they will think that you are bad at listening.  And that is bad!  But if they haven’t told you that, then YES you can send a LOR.  Schools however would rather NOT hear from your academic advisors—you should have your business partner send a rec—especially if this person is older than you, more experienced, etc.  You do not want a peer rec, and ideally you also do not want a teacher either.  Other than those two catagories, you should be in good shape.  Give it a shot!  Just don’t do anything that the adcom asked you NOT to do…

Jon Frank

pxc217

Jon哥 问题提得具体点 你觉得沃顿和耶鲁这两个都可以提交吗？

Hey there!  If the school has specifically told you NOT to submit anything, then of course you need to do what they request.  If you do not follow their directions, they will think that you are bad at listening.  And that is bad!  But if they haven’t told you that, then YES you can send a LOR.  Schools however would rather NOT hear from your academic advisors—you should have your business partner send a rec—especially if this person is older than you, more experienced, etc.  You do not want a peer rec, and ideally you also do not want a teacher either.  Other than those two catagories, you should be in good shape.  Give it a shot!  Just don’t do anything that the adcom asked you NOT to do…

Jon Frank

-- by 会员 JonFrank (2011/1/24 9:18:37)

JonFrank

Jon哥 问题提得具体点 你觉得沃顿和耶鲁这两个都可以提交吗？

Hey there!  If the school has specifically told you NOT to submit anything, then of course you need to do what they request.  If you do not follow their directions, they will think that you are bad at listening.  And that is bad!  But if they haven’t told you that, then YES you can send a LOR.  Schools however would rather NOT hear from your academic advisors—you should have your business partner send a rec—especially if this person is older than you, more experienced, etc.  You do not want a peer rec, and ideally you also do not want a teacher either.  Other than those two catagories, you should be in good shape.  Give it a shot!  Just don’t do anything that the adcom asked you NOT to do…

Jon Frank

-- by 会员 JonFrank (2011/1/24 9:18:37)

-- by 会员 pxc217 (2011/1/24 13:13:20)

Hey there—you know, this year I haven’t read the Yale Wait List letter.  But I know for sure that Wharton is VERY clear in their wording—do NOT send any additional info.  If they are that clear, then we do need to follow directions.   Following directions is the key—no new materials, in the case of Wharton, means exactly that…


Jon Frank

taiwaneseg

岔個題，Yale並非M7阿~

bigjoe

yale可以交的

grimmy

“But I know for sure that Wharton is VERY clear in their wording—do NOT send any additional info.  If they are that clear, then we do need to follow directions.   Following directions is the key—no new materials, in the case of Wharton, means exactly that…”

所以只能等了。。。