再问！GWD31-Q9

saya630

As a pianist, composer, scholar, and essayist on a variety of learned subjects, among the most gifted and versatile musicians of his time was Camille Saint-Saens(1835-1921) who was, as many of his contemporaries were, deeply interested in Oriental themes.

A.As a pianist ,composer, scholar, and essayist on a variety of learned subjects, among the most gifted and versatile musicians of his time was Camille Saint-Saens (1835-1921), who was

B.As a pianist, composer, scholar, and essayist on a variety of earned subjects, Camille Saint-Saens (1835-1921) was among the most gifted and versatile Musicians of his time and having been

C.Pianist, composer, scholar, and essayist on a variety of learned subjects, among the most gifted and versatile musicians of his time was Camille Saint-Saens(1835-1921), and he was

D.Pianist, composer, scholar, and essayist on a variety of learned subjects, Camille Saint-Saens (1835-1921) was among the most gifted and versatile musicians of his time and was

E.Pianist, composer, scholar, and essayist on a variety of learned subjects, Camille Saint-Saens (1835-1921), who was, among the musicians of his time, one of the most gifted and versatile, had been


怎么理解这道题目？？？
麻烦大家了！

luoiszhong

我觉得答案是D。
Pianist, composer, scholar, and essayist on a variety of learned subjects, 做的是主语Camille Saint-Saens 的同位结构,后面两个并列的句子主语都是Camille Saint-Saens。 句子结构很完整。

A选项里面的a很奇怪，因为后面跟了不止一个身份，而且subjects用的是复数形式。同位结构跟一个倒装感觉结构比较混乱，有点指代不清楚。排除A
B选项同A。排除B。
C选项同位结构跟倒装感觉结构混乱。排除C
E选项Camille Saint-Saens (1835-1921), who was, among the musicians of his time, one of the most gifted and versatile后面好像没有宾语吧。
这是本人第一次回答问题，也不知道答得对不对，还请NN指点!!!(真的好紧张啊，因为完全不知道是不是该这样分析）

saya630

我觉得你分析的很好！！谢谢

hsmanbu

我觉得E选项中one of the most gifted and versatile就是表语，among the musicians of his time只是插入成分，这个选项是因为时态不对排除的吧