[求助]请大家帮忙看看这两道GWD题的区别(GWD-24-Q20 vs GWD7-Q4)

aeoluseros

GWD-24-Q 20:

According to a 1996 survey by the National Association of College andUniversity Business Officers, more than three times as many independentinstitutions of higher education charge tuition and fees of under $8,000 ayear than those that charge over $16,000.

A.than those that charge
B.than are charging
C.than to charge
D.as charge
E.as those charging

感觉选D， as 作关系代词。 比如
He eat as many oranges as are available.    As many students go to college as stay at home.  

如果要选E ，应该是个there be 句型吧
There are as many institutes charging under $10,000 as those charging over $16,000
charing $... 作为一个修饰的成分

请高人指点下呀

-- by 会员 eshopaholic (2010/10/5 16:05:30)

嗯，对的，不过there be句型与as...as搭配的时候通常补出there are.
如：153.A recent United States Census Bureau report shows that there are more than three times as many households where the children and grandchildren are living in their grandparents' home as there are households where the grandparents are living in their children's or grandchildren's home.

elaineyll

受教了

angela7258

支持 GWD-24-Q20 D 选项！

sdcar2010

I would go with answer E.

yuicecold

怎么看怎么觉得GWD7-Q4中的b别扭，我用b把句子简单化出来：Only seven people have been killed by the great white shark fewer than have been killed by bee stings.  fewer than后的比较从句就省略了主语，但只有当比较从句的主语与主句的主语相同时，比较从句的主句才能省略，这么说来，b中既然省略了比较从句的主语，即认定其主语与主句相同，为seven people，那最后的结果就是用被大白鲨吃的这7个人与被蜜蜂蛰的同样7个人作比较，这样岂不是违背原句意思吗？
哪位高人再给讲解讲解，E中的the ones是不是可以只指代people，而不特指seven people

alex2610

怎么看怎么觉得GWD7-Q4中的b别扭，我用b把句子简单化出来：Only seven people have been killed by the great white shark fewer than have been killed by bee stings.  fewer than后的比较从句就省略了主语，但只有当比较从句的主语与主句的主语相同时，比较从句的主句才能省略，这么说来，b中既然省略了比较从句的主语，即认定其主语与主句相同，为seven people，那最后的结果就是用被大白鲨吃的这7个人与被蜜蜂蛰的同样7个人作比较，这样岂不是违背原句意思吗？
哪位高人再给讲解讲解，E中的the ones是不是可以只指代people，而不特指seven people

-- by 会员 yuicecold (2010/11/16 15:08:07)

主要是后面还有一个movies会造成the ones指代不清，所以the ones用在这里不好 如果没有movies应该都可以指代，从句意上判断~~

Raymond_GMAT

争议题，还在继续。。。。。。

cutenancymyn

I would go with answer E.

-- by 会员 sdcar2010 (2010/11/10 11:40:08)

能解释一下你为什么选E嘛？

cutenancymyn

GWD-24-Q 20:

According to a 1996 survey by the National Association of College andUniversity Business Officers, more than three times as many independentinstitutions of higher education charge tuition and fees of under $8,000 ayear than those that charge over $16,000.

A.than those that charge
B.than are charging
C.than to charge
D.as charge
E.as those charging

感觉选D， as 作关系代词。 比如
He eat as many oranges as are available.    As many students go to college as stay at home.  

如果要选E ，应该是个there be 句型吧
There are as many institutes charing under $10,000 as those charging over $16,000
charing $... 作为一个修饰的成分

请高人指点下呀

-- by 会员 eshopaholic (2010/10/5 16:05:30)

为什么如果选E，就应该是个there be句型呢~？those这个地方不会产生歧义么~？可以指代 fees 的吧~~所以就歧义了

-- by 会员 魏小妞要出国 (2010/10/5 19:37:12)

如果选E的话 charging 这个分词是做什么成分呢？

iloveus

支持D

我觉得d更简洁啊，而且e中的charging的形式不对吧，对称结构中的词不是不能随意改变形式的吗