再问prep 150，关于同位语

dogshead

150. (33009-!-item-!-188;#058&006530)
The computer company has announced that it will purchase the color-printing division of a rival

company for $950 million, which is part of a deal that will make it the largest manufacturer in the

office color-printing market.
(A) million, which is part of a deal that will make

(B) million, a part of a deal that makes

(C) million, part of a deal making

(D) million as a part of a deal to make

(E) million as part of a deal that will make

C的错误有人解释为part a deal在前面找不到对应的同位对象。但是有些总结前面句子意思的同位语不需要一定有相同的词语出现在前面句子中的（有题，记不得了）。比如这里，我认为即使前面句子没有deal这个词语，deal仍然可以做同位语。这样的话只能是making出问题了。making这里表示状态或者进行都不合适，因为说的是将来的目的。

请NN comments

elaineyoung

mycontrol01 发表于 2009-12-19 11:14
同位语的话就是修饰主语或者宾语 这个位置并没有优先级 靠逻辑分析LZ给的题里 ABC里part/a part都是名词性 ...

翻老题，给大家提个醒：Ron对D答案的解释：if you use the infinitive "to make", then the computer company is still the subject of the sentence. therefore, in this case you have to use the reflexive pronoun: itself. as an analogy, i can't look at me in the mirror, but i can look at myself in the mirror. same deal.

http://www.manhattanprep.com/gmat/forums/the-computer-company-has-announced-that-it-will-purchase-the-t2673.html

cynthia627

这道题我也有疑问。那个as是做什么用的呢？承接哪里呢？希望高人指点！谢谢！

仙蒂瑞拉

The computer company has announced that it will purchase the color-printing division of a rival

company for $950 million, which is part of a deal that will make it the largest manufacturer in the

office color-printing market.(题目要表达的意思是：purchase the color-printing division of a rival

company 是 a deal  的一部分。而不是： $950 million 是 a deal 的一部分。)
(A) million, which is part of a deal that will make（which修饰million 错）

(B) million, a part of a deal that makes（a part修饰million 错）

(C) million, part of a deal making（part修饰million 错）
(D) million as a part of a deal to make

(E) million as part of a deal that will make(purchase the division for 950 million as part of deal )正确

把题目的逻辑意思看懂就好做啦～～做SC题千万要看意思啊～～

不知道讲的对不对～请LZ见谅啊！

cynthia627

啊！我明白了！谢谢楼上的~~~

dogshead

LS没理解我的意思哦。同位语不一定是跟着同位对象的， part of deal 是前句的总结性同位语，而不是前面的$950 million的同位语。看看下面的题

61. (27648-!-item-!-188;#058&003611)

Researchers in Germany have unearthed 400,000-year-old wooden spears from what it appears

was an ancient lakeshore hunting ground as stunning evidence of human ancestors who

systematically hunted big game much earlier than believed.

(A) it appears was an ancient lakeshore hunting ground as stunning evidence of human ancestors

who

(B) it appears had been an ancient lakeshore hunting ground and is stunning evidence that human

ancestors

(C) it appears to have been an ancient lakeshore hunting ground and is stunning evidence that

human ancestors

(D) appears to be an ancient lakeshore hunting ground, stunning evidence that human ancestors

(E) appears that it is an ancient lakeshore hunting ground, stunning evidence of human ancestors

who

仙蒂瑞拉

LZ啊LZ~我不能再看你的例子了～本来我很清楚的～现在有点搞了～～如果LZ近期考可以跟我一样找找feeling.有些选项长得就像正确答案～～

cynthia627

唉，我也是近期。就是22.我来解释。
这个同位语，一般就是修饰主语和宾语。就像61的这个句子， 400,000-year-old wooden spears 这个就是stunning evidnce。但是吧，原来那个句子这么样解释是不对的。我们把宾语找出来是division，这总不是那个的一部分吧？应该是买什么是这个的一部分~

dogshead

谢谢LS两位，我21考，突然发现自己开始怀疑一切了
以前不犹豫就会选的现在想的很多。。。

cynthia627

唉，我这两天，突然看不下去了。主要是一看就觉得超级的紧张……我现在都不敢轻易做题了。我怕到时候错一片，没信心了……

mycontrol01

同位语的话就是修饰主语或者宾语 这个位置并没有优先级 靠逻辑分析

LZ给的题里 ABC里part/a part都是名词性引导的句子所以只能做同位语,而明显这个DEAL是指整个收购计划而不是指的主语或者宾语 因此ABC排除

至于D...想不出硬伤 是不是那个a deal to make暗含了一个"交易的目的是使公司成为第一大的"而有了歧义? 原文意思应该是"这个PURCHASE的发生使公司成为了第一大"  逻辑不同


做题的时候我觉得必须把握住题目想问的逻辑啊..