[求助]OG12-50 定语从句的关系代词that

Jessielynn

50. According to some analysts, the gains in the stock market reflect growing confidence that the economy will avoid the recession that many had feared earlier in the year and instead come in for a “soft landing,” followed by a gradual increase in business activity.

(A) that the economy will avoid the recession that many had feared earlier in the year and instead come

(B) in the economy to avoid the recession, what many feared earlier in the year, rather to come

(C) in the economy’s ability to avoid the recession, something earlier in the year many had feared, and instead to come

(D) in the economy to avoid the recession many were fearing earlier in the year, and rather to come

(E) that the economy will avoid the recession that was feared earlier this year by many, with it instead coming

答案是A我没选错，我问的是OG关于D的解释：the
            recession must be followed by that

这里many were fearing应该是做定语从句的，那么recession在定语从句里是处于宾语的位置，那that应该可以省略啊，为什么说不能省呢？（且不管many were fearing这个表述是不对的。。。）

求解！谢谢~~

tibet

我觉得应该可以省，可能怕歧义吧。

OG的解释我也没当真理看。错的地方都是too wordy，正确的是idiom

Jessielynn

嗯。。。我也觉得OG的解释有时候很笼统。。。动不动就是wordy and awkward，有蒙混过关的嫌疑~

tibet

这个网址推荐给lz吧

我也是刚刚开始攻克SC大家一起学习

http://www.dailywritingtips.com/

挺多好东东的

[此贴子已经被作者于2009/10/15 23:42:01编辑过]

红尘道士

50. According to some analysts, the gains in the stock market reflect growing confidence that the economy will avoid the recession that many had feared earlier in the year and instead come in for a “soft landing,” followed by a gradual increase in business activity.
(A) that the economy will avoid the recession that many had feared earlier in the year and instead come

(B) in the economy to avoid the recession, what many feared earlier in the year, rather to come

(C) in the economy’s ability to avoid the recession, something earlier in the year many had feared, and instead to come

(D) in the economy to avoid the recession many were fearing earlier in the year, and rather to come

(E) that the economy will avoid the recession that was feared earlier this year by many, with it instead coming
答案是A我没选错，我问的是OG关于D的解释：the
           recession must be followed by that

这里many were fearing应该是做定语从句的，那么recession在定语从句里是处于宾语的位置，那that应该可以省略啊，为什么说不能省呢？（且不管many were fearing这个表述是不对的。。。）
求解！谢谢~~

-- by 会员 Jessielynn (2009/10/15 22:48:00)

我感觉that many were fearing 引导的是同位语从句，和confidence that 一样都是同位语从句

红尘道士

浅谈同位语从句和定语从句的区别


在教学中，同位语从句和定语从句是个难点。为了帮助老师和同学们解决这个难点，现就同位语从句和定语从句的区别谈谈自己的一点看法。同位语从句和定语从句都放在被修饰词的后边，从形式上来看，它们十分相似。从以下几个方面来谈它们的区别。
    1、从句所修饰词的不同。同位语从句所修饰词通常是少数一些表示抽象意义的名词，如belief , doubt , fact , hope , idea , news , possibility , thought , order , suggestion , wish , answer , information , conclusion , decision , discovery , knowledge , law , opinion , problem , promise , proof , question , report , truth , risk 等。定语从句的先行词可以指人、物等。例如：
 He has told us a fact that drinking too much does harm to our health.他又告诉我们一个事实，过渡饮酒对健康有害。(同位语从句)
    We have no idea that her mother was a professor ten years ago. . 我们不知道她的母亲十年前是个教授。(同位语从句)
This is the book that I bought yesterday. 这是我昨天买的那本书。（定语从句）
 I will never forget the day when I joined the Party. 我将永远不会忘记我入党的那一天。（定语从句）
   2. 连接词的作用不同。连接同位语从句的that只起连接作用，不在从句中担任任何句子成分。whether 和 how 可以引导同位语从句，但不能引导定语从句。关系代词和关系副词除了连接从句的作用外，还在定语从句中充当一定的句子成分，如主语、宾语、定语、表语等。引导定语从句的连接词是关系词，常见的关系代词和关系副词有that , which , who , whose , whom , when , where , why , as，than, but  等。    
The news that he wants to get is whether he will be sent to the countryside.他所想得到的消息是他是否将被派往农村。(定语从句，关系代词that作从句get的宾语。)
   Do you have a doubt whether she will be dismissed from school? 你怀疑她是否能被学校开除吗？(同位语从句)
   I have no idea how his parents were sad on hearing that their son was killed in the earthquake. 我不知道他的父母一听到他在地震中阵亡是多么悲伤！(同位语从句)
     3. 从句作用的不同。定语从句具有形容词或副词的特点，对先行词起修饰、限定作用，描述先行词的性质或特征，与先行词之间是所属关系。同位语从句具有名词的特点，对中心词作进一步补充解释，是中心词的具体内容。例如：
     The man that you saw just now is my bother. 你刚才看到的那个人是我的弟弟。(定语从句)
    The suggestion that the meeting be put off proved right.推迟会议的建议证明是正确得。（同位语从句）
    The suggestion that he had made is that the meeting be put off. 他提出的建议推迟会议。（定语从句）
      4. 正确理解和使用同位语从句，还应注意以下几点：
    A.分隔同位语从句：有时同位语从句与其先行词被其它成分分隔开来，这种分隔主要出于修辞原因，即为了保持句子结构平衡，避免头重脚轻。
   The whole truth came out at last that he was a wolf in sheep‘s clothing . 真相终于大白了，他原来是只披着羊皮的狼。
   An order has come from Beijing that these thieves will be sentenced to death .
   B.在某些名词后的同位语从句中，其谓语动词应用虚拟语气形式：（should） + 动词原形。常见的名词有advice , idea , order , demand , plan , proposal , suggestion , request 等。例如：
   The suggestion that a new bridge (should) be built was accepted . 采纳了在这里修建一座新桥的建议。
   C.同位语从句的先行词往往没有复数形式。例如：
   他要来教我们英语的消息昨天我就听说了。
   （正）The message that he would teach us English reached me yesterday .
   （误）The messages that he would teach us English reached me yesterday .

红尘道士

and instead come in 做什么成分

doomrobin

浅谈同位语从句和定语从句的区别
在教学中，同位语从句和定语从句是个难点。为了帮助老师和同学们解决这个难点，现就同位语从句和定语从句的区别谈谈自己的一点看法。同位语从句和定语从句都放在被修饰词的后边，从形式上来看，它们十分相似。从以下几个方面来谈它们的区别。
    1、从句所修饰词的不同。同位语从句所修饰词通常是少数一些表示抽象意义的名词，如belief , doubt , fact , hope , idea , news , possibility , thought , order , suggestion , wish , answer , information , conclusion , decision , discovery , knowledge , law , opinion , problem , promise , proof , question , report , truth , risk 等。定语从句的先行词可以指人、物等。例如：
 He has told us a fact that drinking too much does harm to our health.他又告诉我们一个事实，过渡饮酒对健康有害。(同位语从句)
    We have no idea that her mother was a professor ten years ago. . 我们不知道她的母亲十年前是个教授。(同位语从句)
This is the book that I bought yesterday. 这是我昨天买的那本书。（定语从句）
 I will never forget the day when I joined the Party. 我将永远不会忘记我入党的那一天。（定语从句）
   2. 连接词的作用不同。连接同位语从句的that只起连接作用，不在从句中担任任何句子成分。whether 和 how 可以引导同位语从句，但不能引导定语从句。关系代词和关系副词除了连接从句的作用外，还在定语从句中充当一定的句子成分，如主语、宾语、定语、表语等。引导定语从句的连接词是关系词，常见的关系代词和关系副词有that , which , who , whose , whom , when , where , why , as，than, but  等。    
The news that he wants to get is whether he will be sent to the countryside.他所想得到的消息是他是否将被派往农村。(定语从句，关系代词that作从句get的宾语。)
   Do you have a doubt whether she will be dismissed from school? 你怀疑她是否能被学校开除吗？(同位语从句)
   I have no idea how his parents were sad on hearing that their son was killed in the earthquake. 我不知道他的父母一听到他在地震中阵亡是多么悲伤！(同位语从句)
     3. 从句作用的不同。定语从句具有形容词或副词的特点，对先行词起修饰、限定作用，描述先行词的性质或特征，与先行词之间是所属关系。同位语从句具有名词的特点，对中心词作进一步补充解释，是中心词的具体内容。例如：
     The man that you saw just now is my bother. 你刚才看到的那个人是我的弟弟。(定语从句)
    The suggestion that the meeting be put off proved right.推迟会议的建议证明是正确得。（同位语从句）
    The suggestion that he had made is that the meeting be put off. 他提出的建议推迟会议。（定语从句）
      4. 正确理解和使用同位语从句，还应注意以下几点：
    A.分隔同位语从句：有时同位语从句与其先行词被其它成分分隔开来，这种分隔主要出于修辞原因，即为了保持句子结构平衡，避免头重脚轻。
   The whole truth came out at last that he was a wolf in sheep‘s clothing . 真相终于大白了，他原来是只披着羊皮的狼。
   An order has come from Beijing that these thieves will be sentenced to death .
   B.在某些名词后的同位语从句中，其谓语动词应用虚拟语气形式：（should） + 动词原形。常见的名词有advice , idea , order , demand , plan , proposal , suggestion , request 等。例如：
   The suggestion that a new bridge (should) be built was accepted . 采纳了在这里修建一座新桥的建议。
   C.同位语从句的先行词往往没有复数形式。例如：
   他要来教我们英语的消息昨天我就听说了。
   （正）The message that he would teach us English reached me yesterday .
   （误）The messages that he would teach us English reached me yesterday .

-- by 会员 红尘道士 (2009/12/3 20:02:01)

感谢红尘道士！写的很详细~

红尘道士

recession that many had feared earlier in the year and instead come in for a “soft landing,” followed by a gradual increase in business activity.
衰退that很多人年初害怕and却来了软着陆，被逐步增加的商业活动跟随
instead come in 的主语是什么？
followed by a gradual increase in business activity.修饰的又是谁？

rose86511

浅谈同位语从句和定语从句的区别
 
     3. 从句作用的不同。定语从句具有形容词或副词的特点，对先行词起修饰、限定作用，描述先行词的性质或特征，与先行词之间是所属关系。同位语从句具有名词的特点，对中心词作进一步补充解释，是中心词的具体内容。例如：
     The man that you saw just now is my bother. 你刚才看到的那个人是我的弟弟。(定语从句)
    The suggestion that the meeting be put off proved right.推迟会议的建议证明是正确得。（同位语从句）
    The suggestion that he had made is that the meeting be put off. 他提出的建议推迟会议。（定语从句）
     

-- by 会员 红尘道士 (2009/12/3 20:02:01)

从这一点看，OG12-50这道题中recession后接的应该是定语从句，而不是同位语从句，因为从句部分并没有解释这种recession是什么，而是讲人们对recession的担忧，是一种修饰。

即使是同位语从句，请问同位语从句中that不能省略吗？

抛开D选项其他错误的地方，还是不明白为什么“the recession must be followed by that” ?

恳请牛牛们解答~~~~~~