og 225

paopaodong

225. Minnesota is the only one of the contiguous forty-eight states that still has a sizable wolf population, and where this predator remains the archenemy of cattle and sheep.fficeffice" />

(A) that still has a sizable wolf population, and where

(B) that still has a sizable wolf population, where

(C) that still has a sizable population of wolves, and where

(D) where the population of wolves is still sizable;

(E) where there is still a sizable population of wolves and where

Choice D is grammatically constructed, but it lacks a conjunction that establishes a logical relation between the clauses; since Minnesota as a grammatical subject is separated from the clause following the semicolon, the statement there need not even pertain to Minnesota.

    这段解释是什么意思阿

ca3ltoys

which one is the best answer? A? right?


1. according to this predator, we can eliminate answer C D E for the term "wolves" can not represent this predator.


2. for B, we don't know which part "where" clause act as.　There is a comma before where, therefore, "where" here should act as an unlimited clause, but it can't mismodify population.

ca3ltoys

检讨错误.水平有限,请原谅.


根据and where和where前面的逗号可以排除A B C, 但D为什不对,理解还是有问题.


但看过OG的解释还是不明白.请大牛们详细解释一下,谢谢.

cocoabean

那  where there is still a sizable population of wolves, and where this predator remains the archenemy of cattle and sheep  加个逗号是否对?

autumn_leaves

本人看法:

加了逗号后面的WHERE就是状语从句,就导致与前面定从的不平行,即使前后都是WHERE,不加逗号则是两个定从的平行,正确.望指正..

joe11

Choice D is grammatically constructed, but it lacks a conjunction that establishes a logical relation between the clauses; since Minnesota as a grammatical subject is separated from the clause following the semicolon, the statement there need not even pertain to Minnesota.

选项 D 语法正确，但是与原因间的表述没有逻辑关系； 由于 语法主语Minnesota 与其修饰从句被分号分开，使得句子和 Minnesota 不大相关。

白话：按照 D ，this predator remains the archenemy of cattle and sheep 是独立句子，和其要修饰的逻辑成分Minnesota无关了。

但是， where there is still a sizable population of wolves and where this predator remains the archenemy of cattle and sheep 都是修饰 Minnesota 的。

sammaijgd

以下是引用ca3ltoys在2004-3-13 2:09:00的发言：

根据and where和where前面的逗号可以排除A B C, 题.

怎么排除的?

howardwang

以下是引用sammaijgd在2005-8-8 16:56:00的发言：

怎么排除的?

我认为根本没有道理，不可能排除。and 是连词，连接几个并列的成分时，其前通常既可以有逗号，也可以没有。都是对的。

christy42728

引自GWD语法笔记，看似能解决此题争议，排除ABC，不知有没有人见过“l 二重并列不能用逗号 的

”反例，要是没有的话就立为山规了

”反例，要是没有的话就立为山规了

并列的解题步骤：
   

并列的含义：所有的有对应关系的都叫并列，包括同位语，独立主格，and，or连接的两个纯并列句不考虑，但是and,or连接的并列结构属于并列, but 连接的前后两部分要完全对应(but是取非的意思)

l 谁和谁并列（看结构功能是否对应）
   

l 二重并列不能用逗号
    

l 三重以上只能用and, or 引导，其他都不行，并列只能在最后用逗号＋and

l 两个句子中间要用“and”连
   

l 对于具体词，只要不是自己和自己比就不能用it（虚词除外，例如通货膨胀）
   

第四步：比选项
   

[此贴子已经被作者于2008-5-4 23:19:52编辑过]

rolar

我觉得这道题第一考and的并列，后面的和前面的词性，形式等要并列；第二考句子逻辑关系，听说现在实考加强这方面考试了。不知道对不对，请大N指教！