[求助]非常非常急切的再请教各位NN大全757

summergal

5. The Forbidden City in Beijing, from which the emperors ruled by heavenly mandate, was a site which a commoner or foreigner could not enter without any permission, on pain of death.

(A) which a commoner or foreigner could not enter without any permission,

(B) which a commoner or foreigner could enter without any permission only

(C) which no commoner or foreigner could enter without permission,

(D) which, without permission, neither commoner or foreigner could only enter,（C）

(E) which, to enter without permission, neither commoner or foreigner could do

想问各位,在GMAT里，which不是只能用于非限定从句吗（一般中间有逗号）？为什么这里直接跟在要修饰的名词后面呢？

还有B，是不是意思变成：平民和外国人都可以没有许可地进入，违则处死，意思和原句要表达的意思相反？

严重感谢大家！！！

summergal

ding...

summergal

请大家帮忙!

serendipityh

没有死规定! 这里都是带which的.
B是

summergal

谢谢楼上MM,所以这道题用排除法吗?考试遇到这种题就完了......

sunyan730

费限制性定语从句既可以修饰前面的句子也可以修饰前面的词。

summergal

楼上GG, 对呀,这我明白-但就是不明白WHICH前面为什么没逗号，GMAT里面which非限定修饰时一般情况都是有逗号的...

serendipityh

GMAT 没有完全正确的选项, 只有相对正确的选项

你举个有逗号的例子出来!要不没法讨论！

这句加逗号的话感觉别扭

    

先举个例的再说吧！两个也行，　有逗号的

serendipityh

如果把中间的插入语去掉，　然后加逗号，句子就会变成这样
The Forbidden City in Beijing was a site, which a commoner or foreigner could not enter without any permission, on pain of death.
感觉中间的which像插入语, 逻辑意思就变态了, 你把中间which 部分拿掉就知道到了,
插入语踢掉有利于理解句子

summergal

以下是引用serendipityh在2009/9/14 10:39:00的发言：
如果把中间的插入语去掉，　然后加逗号，句子就会变成这样
The Forbidden City in Beijing was a site, which a commoner or foreigner could not enter without any permission, on pain of death.
感觉中间的which像插入语, 逻辑意思就变态了, 你把中间which 部分拿掉就知道到了,
插入语踢掉有利于理解句子

谢谢楼上mm！是不是去掉which成分，后面的on pain of death就变成修饰site,就错了？