GWD-2-Q34求助:现在完成时分词形式到底能不能做定语修饰？

guyiyu1987

NASA’s methodical approach to the exploration of Mars has not yet answered the questions of whether biological life forms ever emerged on Mars and whether, presuming such life forms having left fossil traces to begin with, those traces can still exist in some moist recesses of the cold and arid planet.

A.   and whether, presuming such life forms having left fossil traces to begin with, those traces can

B.    and whether, if it is presumed that such life forms left some fossil traces to begin with, can those traces

C.   and whether, presuming such life forms left fossil traces to begin with, those traces

D.   and, presuming such life forms did leave some fossil traces to begin with, if they can

E.    and, presuming such life forms to have left fossil traces to begin with, if they

答案为A，我选了C

疑惑：

白勇的语法全解上说现在完成时形式的分词不能做定语修饰名词，可是A中 having left 。。。不就是修饰life forms了吗

[此贴子已经被作者于2009/8/29 17:28:18编辑过]

lijiahui0422

我觉得这里的having left不是做的定语

你想想定语是修饰成分，也就是去掉之后句子依然完整，但是你把A中的having去掉后， presuming such life forms. 已经不是一个完整的句子了，个人觉着这里是做补语

其实也就相当于presuming that such life forms have left some fossil trace ... 应该可以看出来不是修饰关系

C 宾语从句的that是不能省略的，情态动词也不能随意去掉

happyjd

郁闷阿，这个题究竟选什么？哪位大牛冒个泡？

新东方的讲解网站上居然说选B,理由如下：

“划线部分第一个词是and, 这决定了前后必须对称，由于划线部分前面是whether，所以D和E后面的if都错了。A和C有个非常严重的错误，presuming这个分词是没有动作的发出者的，逻辑发生错误。”

http://shanghai.neworiental.org/publish/portal25/tab7886/info268172.htm

我只知道DE一定错...到底选什么？

[此贴子已经被作者于2009/8/12 9:56:24编辑过]

lijiahui0422

B里面都不是陈述语序...

guyiyu1987

难道这道题就没有解了吗？我不是很清楚二楼的解释。

yangj206

铁定选A

and whether（, presuming such life forms having left fossil traces to begin with, ）those traces can

whether those traces can...；presuming的主语是隐含的

B里边“if it is presumed that”太啰嗦了；whether can those traces 也不成立

cllcchocolat

同意楼上的,当中的就是插入语，跳掉不看,就是and whether those traces can,而且can是情态动词，省略了意思就有点变化了

guyiyu1987

对，现在我知道情态动词can尽量不能省，但是对于having dong这个是否是后置定语修饰，还是没能得到合理清楚的解释啊

caopp

dingding  期待解答

xxxyyyzzz1

问题是如果presuming引导的是插于语，或者整个是定语，可以不看，那后面的those指代谁呢？V-ing是否是修饰整个句子？