大全section21-9

snow_mountain

9.                 The auto industry has experienced one of its most significant trends in the last 50 years, which is the migration of motorists from passenger cars to minivans, sport utility vehicles, and pickups.

(A) The auto industry has experienced one of its most significant trends in the last 50 years, which is

(B) Of the trends the auto industry experienced in the last 50 years has been one of the most significant

(C) In the last 50 years, one of the most significant trends that the auto industry has been experiencing has been

(D) One of the most significant trends that the auto industry has experienced in the last 50 years is

(E) In the last 50 years, the auto industry experienced one of the most significant trends that it has had, that of

    

答案D。为什么不选C？

dansy

bryony, 这题问得好，我还真不清楚它的语法错误。我只能说一般说一个因素，像陈述一个事实，用现在时比较好吧？虽然它跟了一个可以用现在完成时的时间状语。


大家的意见呢？


UP！

snow_mountain

我也这么convince 自己的。不过这个C总让摸不找具体的错误。


比如说这么个句子：


Up to now, there has been no effective treatment for AIDS.     --from Longman


这应该也是一个事实呀。感觉自己有点绕进去了。


请继续讨论。

snow_mountain

up.

tangyi79

(C) In the last 50 years, one of the most significant trends that the auto industry has been experiencing has been


has been experiencing     没有依据啊，不能作为答案


    

snow_mountain

以下是引用tangyi79在2004-3-5 15:16:00的发言：
(C) In the last 50 years, one of the most significant trends that the auto industry has been experiencing has been



has been experiencing     没有依据啊，不能作为答案


    

可是in the last 50 Years,就是表示完成态的时间呀。

HZDCB

has experienced强调的是 从过去的一段时间到现在 所经历的事
has been experiencing除了强调 从过去到现在外，还强调这个事可能 持续到将来
in the last 50 years强调的是从过去到现在的一段时间，没有对未来的一种可能性，所以用has experienced更好一些
另外就像dansy说的一样，这是事实，所以C的第二个has been不是很好

个人见解