一道SC题

sly2009

Nine months after the county banned jet skis and other water bikes from the tranquil waters of Puget Sound, a judge overturned the ban on the ground of violating state laws for allowing the use of personal watercraft on common waterways.

	of violating state laws for allowing
	of their violating state laws to allow
	that it violates state laws that allowed
	that it violated state laws allowing
	that state laws were being violated allowing

	of violating state laws for allowing
	of their violating state laws to allow
	that it violates state laws that allowed
	that it violated state laws allowing
	that state laws were being violated allowing

A.       of violating state laws for allowing

B.       of their violating state laws to allow

C.       that it violates state laws that allowed

D.       that it violated state laws allowing

E.       that state laws were being violated allowing

答案选D，可是我觉得这里it指代不清啊，为什么选这个答案呢？B为什么不可以，"their"可不可以表示jet skis, water bikes?请各位NN看看。

a02702

From the meaning of the main sentenance: 'it' should refer to 'the ban', and 'the ban' violated state law. So that,'the ban' was overtuned. Any other ideas?

h5641

it 應該是指代 a judge.   從句意著手.

hongrucai

以下是引用h5641在2009-6-3 0:56:00的发言：
it 應該是指代 a judge.   從句意著手.

It 应该指代the ban吧...??

houzhongxu

以下是引用sly2009在2009-6-2 22:48:00的发言：

Nine months after the county banned jet skis and other water bikes from the tranquil waters of Puget Sound, a judge overturned the ban on the ground of violating state laws for allowing the use of personal watercraft on common waterways.

A.       of violating state laws for allowing

B.       of their violating state laws to allow

C.       that it violates state laws that allowed

D.       that it violated state laws allowing

E.       that state laws were being violated allowing

答案选D，可是我觉得这里it指代不清啊，为什么选这个答案呢？B为什么不可以，"their"可不可以表示jet skis, water bikes?请各位NN看看。

昨夜语法之神给我托梦，that是on the ground不可分割的一部分

AB干掉

E的那个BEING不爽，秒杀

CD开比

ing好于从句修饰

做完

it的指代非常清楚，就是那个ban

racing78

of  是介係詞，介係詞後只能跟名詞，所以A,B都不對，因為最後一句話是獨立子句(S+V+O)，所以必須接that作為連接子句之用.E邏輯不通，是Ban violate原來規定可以xx的法律.最後剩下C,D,因為D的時態與前面一致，所以D比較好。