McGill is really terrible

amigo

agree with ccfish

Snazzy

GMAT won't decide everything. A requirement of Verbal 35 is impossible. You've got to look at the whole package. A guy with GMAT score 780 was rejected last year by U of T.

atongmu

对中国人来说之所以进加拿大学校如此困难还有一个重要原因就是2年多时间可以用于“蹲移民监”。

joywzy

其实，还是有很多办法能规避“蹲移民监”。 我奇怪为什么那么多移民选择在加拿大的学校读书？除了费用之外，还有什么原因？（我大学时的校友全家都在montreal读书收，政府还发补贴）。

amigo

试想不用花钱能拿到一个top40的学校的MBA，甚至读书时还能赚钱，吸引力还不大吗？

luckycat

强烈不推荐因为能"拿钱"而选择在MCGILL读书. "赚钱"只是表面的,失去的远比那些小钱多的多.


MCGILL教学不灵活,     实习机会少之又少, 当地好的工作机会少(法语有要求), 工资低.     如果到多伦多去找工作, 那有多大,IVEY的毕业生等着呢.    到美国找, 没有当地学校有竞争力.


俗话说,物有所值, 学费低有它的道理. 学校钱少就吸引不到好教授, 买不起更多的案例和商业软件, 不能提供更多的就业服务.

braveMBA

MCGILL的就业率和薪水水平不敢恭维。FT的排名也欠妥，MCGILL居然能排在KELLEY，等学校的前面，简直是笑话。MCGILL的60%国际学生可能是它的‘金融屎包’排名靠前的原因。不过，MCGILL的UNIVERSITY的声誉还是不错，尤其是它的医学。费用低是它的最吸引人的地方，但是读MBA的投资不光是MONEY，还有时间、效果、前景、质量，这笔帐还真的要好好算。


希望申请MCGILL的XDJM全部有OFFER，管它600还是730的。如果它不要，也不求它，我们还不去了呢。

ccfish

Monteal的大学门槛都是被中国移民哄抬高的，以前都是很好进的，现在申请的人太多，导致Mcgill对中国人不太友好。BraveMBA说的对，读MBA的投资得全面看，不能只局限于学费。

amigo

FT的排名的确令人奇怪，这几年教授水平日渐下降，学校的办事效率和工作人员的态度实在令人不感恭维，不过如果选择将来回国发展，我觉得就它的学校声誉来说来是值的。现在就算top20的学校出来，就业也很困难啊。

Snazzy

Guys, isn't that rediculous that McGill has average GMAT score of 700 among Chinese students, if not more, and the average all is only 640?    It means that the average score of the other ethnics is probably only 620 or even less. I am so confused.


I kind of hesitate, although I am still far from getting an offer, when I learn the fact. If, as a lof of Chinese folks     consider, the tuition is weighed so much when choosing a B-school, I would rather save a seat for somebady else who needs it desperately than go to another 'Qinghua'. I chose McGill simply because of its OK reputation in US and the chance to speak French. But I definately don't want to get involve in a vicious circle.


Since it's not easier to apply for McGill than to apply for top 15 in US, I can not see any reason why I should go for it. Given potential salary difference and overall repution of the schools, tuition is really nothing. Who cares about the extra 30, 000 bucks if you know you are going to get a job which can pay you off within only months?     I just don't buy it.