考试在即，求救Q2: GWD32-Q5

junguo21c

ffice:smarttags">
    

Q2: GWD32-Q5

    

Arctic terns, being true long-distance
migrants, they nest in
            coastal wetlands of northern Europe but fly south for thousands of
miles to spend the European winters in Antarctica.

    

 

    

1. Arctic terns , being true long distance
        migrants, they nest in coastal wetlands of northern Europe
                   
2. Arctic terns are true long distance
        migrants, nesting in coastal wetlands of northern Europe
3. Being that they are true long distance
        migrants, arctic terns nest in coastal wetlands of northern Europe
                   
4. Nesting in coastal wetlands of northern
        Europe, arctic terns are true long
        distant migrants
5. True long distance migrants, arctic
        terns nest in coastal wetlands of northern Europe
                   

    

 我觉得应该是E，但是答案C?

AlienX

I think that the answer is E not C...
C is super wordy.

3bao

我也认为答案是E

C选项太啰嗦，而且在GWD题目里面我感觉只要出现being这个词基本就不用往下看了，一定是错的。

SHJDHKBB9

答案应该还是C

大家注意原句要表达的含义 being true long distance migrants,而C中 arctic terns nest in coastal wetlands of northern Europe  but fly south for thousands of miles to spend the European winters in Antarctica. 作为Being that they are true long distance migrants的后事物或者说"例子"出现,与原文表达含义相同.

而E虽然简洁,但其含义已不同于原文.

试问,在无语法错误情况下,是选与原文表述含义相同但不太简洁的选项,还是选择虽然表述简洁但表述含义已发生改变的选项,大家自己斟酌.

另外大家注意being在大多数情况下错误,但决不可绝对化,还是特事特办为好.

AlienX

umm...沒看出E改變原文的意思...
LZ覺得C跟E的意思有什麼不同呢?

coldghost

I also think it's D, Hehe

junguo21c

谢谢楼上的回复，但是我还是看不出来CE的区别，太笨了，不好意思。
烦请继续指点

k2o33

e有2个重大问题

1.同位语中，后者一般起补充解释作用，逻辑涵盖可以大于前者但不能小于。

2.同位语要加2个逗号，前一个，后一个

e的同位语和主语换换就对了，再加个逗号就对了

a中的同位语有being是不能容忍的

b的对称不对

c的being that虽然wordy，但是意思对，而且没有语法错误，其实c连being true long distance migrants都不如

d的意思不对

crystal007

不知道选哪个。。。 我选E  答案是C   到底是哪个？

DorothyWRSC

E吧

A、B、D错得离谱

C前面很啰唆