MBAHSG Student taking questions NewPics

grainy

问楼上gg费用的问题，有关学校提供覆盖80％多的贷款，偿还部分和期限什么的细节。

HSGMBA

以下是引用grainy在2008-11-9 0:30:00的发言：
问楼上gg费用的问题，有关学校提供覆盖80％多的贷款，偿还部分和期限什么的细节。

关于贷款的偿还，按照合同，好像是从毕业之后，也就是次年的9月开始，每月1400多瑞郎，还两年多。当然也可以提前还完。和美国商学院相比，利息还是比较低的。总额42000的本金，中国同学毕业后工作的起薪120K左右，应该很快还完。

 

http://forums.businessweek.com/n/pfx/forum.aspx?tsn=197&nav=messages&webtag=bw-bschools&tid=73646

这个商业周刊论坛上的答疑贴有这个讨论，你可以参考。

 

myf1

天，都这么做广告了。

圣加伦总是说自己是最好的(德语区)。
和IMD相比，还是差得远吧。

myf1

delete

[此贴子已经被作者于2008-11-13 2:50:47编辑过]

HSGMBA

以下是引用myf1在2008-11-13 2:16:00的发言：
天，都这么做广告了。

圣加伦总是说自己是最好的(德语区)。
和IMD相比，还是差得远吧。

HI, myf1, you meant to compare MBA-HSG with IMD?

First, HSG as a whole is the best in German speaking areas, that's accepted very well.I am assuring you.

Secondly, MBA-HSG is very young, so it will appear in FT ranking only after 2010. We are different from IMD, but this doesn't mean we are as weak as you mentioned...The fact is, we are not weak at all.

If you were a participant of IMD or MBA-HSG, your comments may have some credits, but I doubt it.

If you compare the salary level upon graduation, you may find no such big difference as you imagined:

IMD:Average $ 129,000;

http://www.imd.ch/programs/mba/admissions/upload/Class%20and%20placement%20overview.pdf

MBA-HSG: Average over CHF 120,000;

http://www.mba.unisg.ch/org/es/mba.nsf/wwwContentEng/Placement+Report+2007?opendocument

The reports are both for class 2007.

Yes, CHF and US$ are different, 1US$=CHF1.18, but IT IS THAT DIFFERENT as you suggested?

What's more, here I would shed some lights on why some of participants of my class refused IMD but came here:

换一个角度，我曾经看过一个IMD在读同学的帖子说，每天学习15个小时，每天能睡5个小时都是奢侈。并不是每一个Senior manager都愿意选择这样的MBA生活。

Again, following is a dicussion on businessweek's MBA forum. Many people compared MBA-HSG with IMD, but a declaration like you made is very unusual, given the fact that the discussion is pondered by people from all over the world.

Good luck!

http://forums.businessweek.com/n/pfx/forum.aspx?tsn=177&nav=messages&webtag=bw-bschools&tid=73646

page 19:

As for IMD there are a few reasons, 1.) It's much more expensive, 2.) It's a larger program and you don't get as much individual attention (100 students vs 40), 3.) It is in the french speaking part of Switzerland rather than the German speaking park.  3 may or may not be important to you but most of the job opportunities in the German speaking part of Switzerland (the French part is very small) plus you have Austria and Germany as well.  From what I know German, Austrian and Swiss companies prefer St. Gallen but IMD has more of an international reputation.  St. Gallen will probably have a similar reputation after 2010 when they come out on the financial times rankings - they are not yet listed because the program is new.  Swiss, Germans and Austrians view St. Gallen as the Americans view Harvard and Wharton. 

I applied to LBS, Insead, IESE, Esade, Instituto De Impressa, INSEAD, IMD and SDA Bocconi.  In the end I chose St. Gallen because of the price, the individual attention you get in such a small program (there at least 8 staff members specifically just to support the 43 in addition to the regular faculty and campus wide career services, this does not include our professors) and the fact that you can complete the program in 12 months as compared to 15 - 24 months for many of the other programs.

[此贴子已经被作者于2008-11-13 17:54:51编辑过]

cctv0215

请教LZ,请问该学校能接受托福成绩么？从网站上看，貌似只接受雅思。。。

MACROSHA

IMD:Average $ 129,000;    MBA-HSG: Average over
            CHF
            120,000;        I am an accountant,and I am sensitive to number..... Obviously,IMD is more competitive...by the way....too many indians who account for 20 percent in the class,espically for a German speaking regional school,it is strange....      

HSGMBA

以下是引用cctv0215在2008-11-13 9:15:00的发言：
请教LZ,请问该学校能接受托福成绩么？从网站上看，貌似只接受雅思。。。

I think MBA-HSG would accept T, They only need evidence that you handle English communication well, that's it. But better ask admission office.

HSGMBA

以下是引用MACROSHA在2008-11-13 12:13:00的发言：
IMD:Average $ 129,000;    MBA-HSG: Average over
   CHF
   120,000;        I am an accountant,and I am sensitive to number..... Obviously,IMD is more competitive...by the way....too many indians who account for 20 percent in the class,espically for a German speaking regional school,it is strange....      

Yes, there is difference. 1US$=1.18CHF. 

But obviously not that big difference considering that IMD has a history of over 30 years and MBA-HSG only has 5 years of history! Checking other top b school statistics, you will find many no better than here St Gallen...

And, considering IMD participants hard-work over 15 hours daily and sleep less than 5 hours, I personally think they deserve that difference between IMD statistics and those of St Gallen.

So, it will be a personal preference when deciding on between IMD and MBA-HSG

As for Indians in our class, they are smart guys, one thing you may know, they are as sensitive as you are on finding where is the best place to do MBA. So many MBA applicants from India, they push up GMAT scores of our class.

Nomoredream

以下是引用myf1在2008-11-13 2:16:00的发言：
天，都这么做广告了。

圣加伦总是说自己是最好的(德语区)。
和IMD相比，还是差得远吧。

人家给圣加仑做广告也是一片好意， 让更多的人熟悉HSG， 再说HSG确实是好学校。IMD在法语区， 人家又没有吹嘘自己是瑞士第一，HSG说自己德语区第一，好像没有德语区哪个学校说自己才是第一吧。