GWD-29-Q39 急急急

connie4895

以下是引用stone12321在2008-10-16 16:11:00的发言：

Scientists have recently discovered that the ultrathin, layered construction of a butterfly’s wings, the same as the one making some butterflies shimmer via the phenomenon of iridescence, are enabling the insect to control how much heat energy is absorbed by its wings and how much is reflected away.

 

 

A.      wings, the same as the one making some butterflies shimmer via the phenomenon of iridescence, are enabling

B.       wings, which is the same one that makes some butterflies shimmer via the phenomenon of iridescence, that also enables

C.      wings is the same as the one that makes some butterflies shimmer via the phenomenon of iridescence, enabling

D.      wings－the same construction that makes some butterflies shimmer via the phenomenon of iridescence－also enables

E.       wings－of the same construction that makes some butterflies shimmer via the phenomenon of iridescence－also enable

答案是D

但C为什么不对呢？

跟the one 有关吗？

谢谢NN们～～～～  

C改变句子重心，原本的主要结构变伴随状语，但其实做伴随状语的语意也搭不太起来，此外，相同地位的另一个东西代名词应用that而不是one

yirwang

enabling的修饰对象不唯一

collins822

the ultrathin是超薄的意思,那么为什么ultrathin后面有个万恶的逗号？？！！题干有错吧？

lucyliu

如果C对，带回原句, 变成如下的句子结构形式：
Scientists have discovered that the construction...is the same as the one that makes...via the phenomenon ..., enabling...
这里分词结构，enabling ...可以做定语修饰the phenomenon；或者做discover/is的伴随状语，而根据原句的意思是the construction enables,所以应该是做is的伴随状语。但是，分词结构是不能做系动词的伴随状语的。

pdsb

楼上所言极是

fiona_hq

up

lemuren

以下是引用lucyliu在2008/12/8 5:59:00的发言：

如果C对，带回原句, 变成如下的句子结构形式：
Scientists have discovered that the construction...is the same as the one that makes...via the phenomenon ..., enabling...
这里分词结构，enabling ...可以做定语修饰the phenomenon；或者做discover/is的伴随状语，而根据原句的意思是the construction enables,所以应该是做is的伴随状语。但是，分词结构是不能做系动词的伴随状语的。

说的很好，enabling从语法上来讲逻辑主语应该是科学家，逻辑就错误了。

我一开始看到ultrathin看的太快以为是个什么专业高深的词汇，然后把后面的layers小分句看成了同位语解释ultrathin,结果仔细一看发现原来是ultra..thin...晕死

小羽羽

把形容词ultrathin（超薄的）当成了主语，厄~~~偶太丢人了，还好这里本来就需要单数
看了上面的帖，很有感触，C的结构乍一看喜人，其实错点颇多：
wings is the same as the one that makes some butterflies shimmer via the phenomenon of iridescence, enabling
表述wordy；enable本来是从句中的主动词，现变成了主句的伴随状语，其逻辑主语是Scientists说不通，无法跳跃修饰construction
再看D的结构，真的清爽明白至极
wings—the same construction that makes some butterflies shimmer via the phenomenon of iridescence—also enables
破折号后同位语解释construction，就是这个also当时着实迷惑了一下

sunshengkun666

C有歧义啊，可能是那种PHENOMENON ENABLE的...

像风一样离去

D中的also enables怎么说？麻烦指点指点。