破解PREP2 11题

rwchinak

11.   (25059-!-item-!-188;#058&002009)

Nine months after the county banned jet skis and other water bikes from the tranquil waters of Puget Sound, a judge overturned the ban on the ground of violating state laws for allowing the use of personal watercraft on common waterways.

(A) of violating state laws for allowing

(B) of their violating state laws to allow

(C) that it violates state laws that allowed

(D) that it violated state laws allowing

(E) that state laws were being violated allowing

答案是D

我感觉此题有问题！

我的问题是，D项中的it直待什么？凭什么it一定要指代那个ban？

如果按就近原则，it应该指代ground才对啊

虽然我都觉得这么分析很拽很抬杠，但期待能有个说法

代词指代我太弱了

而E中，虽然罗唆无比且用被动，但毕竟没有正确性错误

[此贴子已经被作者于2008-8-7 19:45:42编辑过]

rwchinak

自己顶

georgetseng

就近原则只有带歧义时适用。it在此句中明显指代ban，指代ground根本不合逻辑，所以不会引起歧义。

shiwen66666

"就近原则只有带歧义时适用".拿什么时候会引起歧义呢？

shiwen66666

ding

shiwen66666

ding

铭HAO

being done 的说法在GMAT 上是禁止的