没有人问过的一点,请教-PREP-1-148

Again

In contrast to some fish eggs requiring months to incubate, the Rio Grande silvery minnow produces eggs that hatch in about 24 hours, yielding larvae that can swim in just three to four days.

 

(A) some fish eggs requiring months to incubate

(B) some fish,
            whose eggs require months to incubate

(C) some fish that have eggs requiring months to incubate

(D) the requirement of months of incubation for some fish eggs

(E) requiring months of incubation, as some fish eggs do

C的have eggs doing确实不好，但我觉得C中的that从句式限制性的，而这里就应该用限制性的修饰对some fish进行限制型修饰。

想反，B中的 whose是非限制型的，我觉得不合适。

但答案确实是B。请指教。

Again

顶一下吧.

tigercaiqun

我觉得是：some fish已经是限制了是部分鱼的意思了，用非限制性定语从句再说明一下。

另外some fish that have eggs的have有些别扭，象后半句用produce好一点吧，have表示一种状态。

希望更好的解释，帮你顶一下。

足球幽灵

同意楼上的。

另外补充一点：sb1 have sb2 doing表示sb1让\使sb2发出doing的动作。放在这里，逻辑不对：“鱼”让“卵”发出“要求”的动作。

tigercaiqun

楼上的强！刚查了词典：

have got [not in progressive]
            especially British English
            used to say that your body or something else is in a particular position or state, because you moved or did something
    

have something open/closed/on etc
        

I had my eyes half-closed.

Janice likes to have the window open.

She had her back to the door.

have something doing something
        

He's always got the stereo playing.

27make somebody do something [not in progressive]
        

a) to affect someone in a way that makes them start doing something
            

have somebody laughing/crying etc
                

Within minutes he had the whole audience laughing and clapping.

b) to persuade or order someone to do something
            

have somebody doing something
                

She had me doing all kinds of jobs for her.

have somebody do something
                    especially American English
                

I'll have Hudson show you to your room.

Again

感谢足球幽灵 和 tigercaiqun感的回答, 通过这题我呈请了我以前对限制性和非限制性的一个错误点，非常感谢。

lichabrend

up

aeoluseros

以下是引用足球幽灵在2008-3-22 11:13:00的发言：

同意楼上的。

另外补充一点：sb1 have sb2 doing表示sb1让\使sb2发出doing的动作。放在这里，逻辑不对：“鱼”让“卵”发出“要求”的动作。

以下是引用tigercaiqun在2008-3-22 10:54:00的发言：

我觉得是：some fish已经是限制了是部分鱼的意思了，用非限制性定语从句再说明一下。

另外some fish that have eggs的have有些别扭，象后半句用produce好一点吧，have表示一种状态。

希望更好的解释，帮你顶一下。

我觉得用非限定性定语从句和限定性定语从句倒是没有什么问题。

some fish have eggs也没有问题，用了produce反而增加了一层含义。B里面的whose eggs不也是表示一种状态吗？

问题是在C中have eggs requiring那样的表达好像是在说：那些鱼除了拥有需要好几个月才孵出来的卵以外还有其他类型的卵

至于have我觉得也没有那重have something doing something的毛病，因为这里的have意思很明显是拥有（鱼再怎么使劲也无法让卵做什么），have something doing something这个短语里面have的意思是make（使）。

NgKKh

4楼正解。

terry9115

为什么回帖都看不到？