[求助]请教大全116

dreadpower

116.Archaeologists in Ireland believe that a recently discovered chalice, which dates from the eighth century, was probably buried to keep from being stolen by invaders.
(A) to keep from
(B) to keep it from
(C) to avoid
(D) in order that it would avoid
(E) in order to keep from
    答案是B。
    OG的解释认为C中的avoid的逻辑主语是chalice，所以是chalice自己避免不被偷，这个没问题。

    按照这个说法，那么A中的keep from的逻辑主语也是chalice，所以也错

    以此类推，那么B选项 keep it from的逻辑主语是不是也应该是chalice呢？？但是it也指代chalice，觉得自己有点糊涂了

    另外：查了一下keep的用法，keep sb / sth from doing sth ，那么根本就不用管逻辑主语嘛

    我自己觉得自己糊涂了，讲了一大堆，不知道自己在讲什么

elfelf

其实题目中keep from 或是avoid真正的逻辑主语应该是somebody，所以B选项就是正确的哦

dreadpower

还是不很理解~~~~

bluestone1

keep from 没有 it, 就容易被理解为 逻辑主语为 chalice；
keep  it from 有 it, it 指代 chalice, 就容易理解为逻辑主语l另有其人

我这是事后诸葛，瞎猜。

dreadpower

呵呵，bluestone1兄的思维和语言都非常透彻，佩服