GWD25-Q20: for doing 与 to do

Hamiton

    

20.
GWD25-Q20

    

Most
states impose limitations on the authority of the legislature to borrow
money, with their objectives being to protect taxpayers and the credit of
the state government.

    

A.    
to borrow money, with their objectives being to protect

    

B.     
to borrow money, the objectives of which are the protecting of

    

C.    
to borrow money, limitations intended to protect

    

D.    
for borrowing money, of which the objective is protecting

    

E.     
for borrowing money, limitations with the intent of protecting

    

答案选C, 但是 impose 的目的不是 to borrow money, 目的不对啊!

倾向选E,  for borrowing money 修饰 legislature; with the intent of doing 也是PREP中出现的正确用法, 欢迎讨论

huangruiyan

以下是引用Hamiton在2007-11-6 10:39:00的发言：

 

20.
GWD25-Q20

 

Most
states impose limitations on the authority of the legislature to borrow
money, with their objectives being to protect taxpayers and the credit of
the state government.

 

A.    
to borrow money, with their objectives being to protect

 

B.     
to borrow money, the objectives of which are the protecting of

 

C.    
to borrow money, limitations intended to protect

 

D.    
for borrowing money, of which the objective is protecting

 

E.     
for borrowing money, limitations with the intent of protecting

 

答案选C, 但是 impose 的目的不是 to borrow money, 目的不对啊!

倾向选E,  for borrowing money 修饰 legislature; with the intent of doing 也是PREP中出现的正确用法, 欢迎讨论

逻辑上也应该选E，
            C的错误在于，states 采用限制措施是为了借钱，明显错误。应该是是采用了限制借钱的措施。E  is right

tonect

以下是引用Hamiton在2007-11-6 10:39:00的发言：

 

20.
GWD25-Q20

 

Most
states impose limitations on the authority of the legislature to borrow
money, with their objectives being to protect taxpayers and the credit of
the state government.

 

A.    
to borrow money, with their objectives being to protect

 

B.     
to borrow money, the objectives of which are the protecting of

 

C.    
to borrow money, limitations intended to protect

 

D.    
for borrowing money, of which the objective is protecting

 

E.     
for borrowing money, limitations with the intent of protecting

 

答案选C, 但是 impose 的目的不是 to borrow money, 目的不对啊!

倾向选E,  for borrowing money 修饰 legislature; with the intent of doing 也是PREP中出现的正确用法, 欢迎讨论

应该选c，to borrow money 是 limitation的后置定语

e的很明显的问题就是，后半句wordy，直接用intended to do最简单

feiyuwuhen12

C选项我理解应该是两个分句啊，中间缺少一个连词？？我也选的E，哪位NN帮忙解释一下

leowz

是独立主格结构，不是分句吧

leowz

个人认为：

to do 比 for doing 好，而且后半句E没有C好，即使是正确的。选最好的最合适的。

rwchinak

1、impose limitation on authority of sb to do sth。

to do不定式逻辑上是修饰authority的。the authority to do sth就是有干什么的权力。

意思是限制立法机关借钱的权力。

而impose limitation on authroity of legislature for borrowing money.

for doing sth逻辑上是修饰legislature的，意思是“用来借钱的立法机关”。逻辑完全错

立法机关不是用来借钱的，是用来立法的。

举个例子吧， a knife for cutting things.

2、huangruiyan的说法是有道理的。C的确会产生歧义。问题在于，在同样的逻辑下，E也有同样的问题

C. states impose limitation on......to borrow money

E. states impose limitation on......for borrowing money

两者都有表达目的的意思。

C和E都有产生歧义的可能，两者在这里地位平等

yzhao26

up

vivian0331

以下是引用tonect在2008-9-23 18:02:00的发言：

应该选c，to borrow money 是 limitation的后置定语

e的很明显的问题就是，后半句wordy，直接用intended to do最简单

关于to borrow money，我认为这个解释是正确的，这里impose limitation on authority of sb to do sth不是impose to do,而是limitation to do...否则，句子逻辑意思不正确。

AlienX

個人看法:
to borrow是修authority.