白勇和OG总结出来的经验在大全里很多行不通，怎么办

ssl507

       大全section a 1.Modern critics are amused by early scholars’ categorizing Tacitus’s Germania as an ethnographic treatise.

(A) scholars’ categorizing Tacitus’s Germania as

(B) scholars’ categorizing Tacitus’s Germania as if

(C) scholars, categorizing of Tacitus’s Germania as

(D) scholars who categorize Tacitus’s Germania as

(E) scholars who categorize Tacitus’s Germania if

白勇说ones'doing 绝对错，这里却是对的

大全section2. Revered by an ill-informed citizenry, the Duke of York was feted opulently for several months before there was denunciation and exile.

(A) there was denunciation and exile

(B) he was to be denounced with exile

(C) being denounced and exiled

(D) denunciation and his exile 

(E) being exiled, having been denounced

og的见到being都是错的，这里却是对的

感觉白勇和OG总结出来的经验在大全里很多行不通，大全错得一塌糊涂，怎么办？

 

(A) there was denunciation and exile

(B) he was to be denounced with exile

(C) being denounced and exiled

(D) denunciation and his exile 

(E) being exiled, having been denounced

og的见到being都是错的，这里却是对的

感觉白勇和OG总结出来的经验在大全里很多行不通，大全错得一塌糊涂，怎么办？

 

alanliwei

Choose the best available answer. I don't see any problem here.

Ironpanda

我也选了D,D

第一题A和D比较，动词优于分词形势，选了D而放弃A。

第二题，D选项还特意把his放在了And的后面，从而进一步消除歧义，一看就很爽......

貌似也错了~~~~

等待高手解答

[此贴子已经被作者于2007-7-10 10:00:58编辑过]

ssl507

 Before I have reviewed og and baiyong, maybe i could choose the correct answer.but now when I see the forms of being and one's doing, I immediately elimiate the answer. 

alanliwei

第一题。。首先，是被early scholar的行为所amused，不是被scholar本人。。其次，categorize应该用过去时吧。。

elithian

spt alanliwei

lz, now you know such rules from by is not working, from true experience~