请教xy05-04

addy

Q4:

Only seven people this century have been killed by the great white shark, the man-eater of the movies—less than those killed by bee stings.

 

1. movies—less than those

2. movies—fewer than have been

3. movies, which is less than those

4. movies, a number lower than the people

5. movies, fewer than the ones

下载的答案说是B,我选了E,在网上搜索了一下,又有人说答案是E,请各位指点一下到底该选哪个,谢谢^_^(总觉得那个have been好奇怪啊,而且觉得它漏了成分)

carolinelmf

但是The ones又好怪

addy

比起来B更怪...我的看法是,如果一定要have been,应该说是fewer than those who have been killed by bee stings(此时have been省略算了)...

stevegt

支持B

A 有两个错误1.less不能修饰人,只能说fewer people 2.than those, 这里的those只能指代people have been killed by the great white shark,这样的话就变成了: people who have been killed by the great white shark have been killed by bee. 显然错误,这个people真倒霉,kill两次.

B对 1.fewer修饰people(understood) 2.时态对,比较前后都是present perfect.

C 错which修饰对象不明确.修饰movies??

D. 1. lower number错. 2.number than people 比较对象错

E 1.fewer指代不明确people ?? movies??  2 .the ones  累赘 应该省略the ones 直接加 助动词