prep2-132 关于than比较疑问

wnbrqchase

132.
            (31781-!-item-!-188;#058&006523)

 

A study published in the British Medical Journal showed that women who ate nuts more than five times a week were about one third less likely to suffer from coronary heart disease as those who ate no nuts at all.

 

(A) as those who ate

(B) as women who ate

(C) as those eating

(D) than women eating

(E) than were those who ate

答案是E， 当时在DE犹豫，根据分词比定从简洁，所以选了D，结果错了

大家指点一下，为什么D是错误的吧，3x！

crowkiller

呵呵，平行最大。

 women   who ate nuts more than five times a week were （about one third less likely to suffer from coronary heart disease ）than   were   those who ate no nuts at all.

E 选项最平行。。。

而且定从和分词修饰有一个范围的差别。请参照 OG10SC 第一题。

[此贴子已经被作者于2007-6-18 11:55:50编辑过]

YY_lalala

以下是引用crowkiller在2007-6-18 11:52:00的发言：

呵呵，平行最大。

 women   who ate nuts more than five times a week were （about one third less likely to suffer from coronary heart disease ）than   were   those who ate no nuts at all.

E 选项最平行。。。

而且定从和分词修饰有一个范围的差别。请参照 OG10SC 第一题。

nice job~

此外，我觉得还可以从主语比较vs.宾语比较的角度看这道题

可参考：http://forum.chasedream.com/dispbbs.asp?BoardID=23&replyID=983810&id=103101&skin=0

wnbrqchase

3X!

crowkiller

以下是引用YY_lalala在2007-6-18 14:16:00的发言：

nice job~

此外，我觉得还可以从主语比较vs.宾语比较的角度看这道题

可参考：http://forum.chasedream.com/dispbbs.asp?BoardID=23&replyID=983810&id=103101&skin=0

同意！D 项需要补出动词强调是主语比较。。

vivian0331

我的疑问是：

为什么E选项用than were those who ate

were提前的情况不应该是有否定词，倒装才会出现这种情况么？

请NN指教！

vivian0331

up

AlienX

than/as...as之後的倒裝是style的問題
倒不倒都okay

vivian0331

以下是引用AlienX在2009-5-18 14:39:00的发言：
than/as...as之後的倒裝是style的問題
倒不倒都okay

是么？那我可不可以这样理解：more...than, as...as中，肯定句助动词是否倒装都可以；否定句一定要倒装。对吧？

AlienX

LS mm是說than/as...as之後是否定?