请教Prep-1-142

floraxycn

142.
                (32496-!-item-!-188;#058&006253)

According to a 1996 study published in the Journal of Human Resources, Americans of Middle Eastern descent were twice as likely as was the national average to be self-employed.

(A) as was the national average to be self-employed

(B) as the average American to be self-employed

(C) as the national average that they would be self-employed

(D) to be self-employed than was the average American

(E) that they would be self-employed than was the national average

答案是B，请问A错在哪里? 谢谢！

Zeldaw

比较结构

Americans of Middle Eastern descent were twice as likely as was the national average to be self-employed.

for a , americans.....as likely as the  national average was

for b,  americans .....as likely as the the average American

alicfine

这道题我也错了，但是我不大同意ls的观点.

A,Americans of...were  as likely as the national average was

B,as the average American to be self-employed

Be 动词是否需要省略要看具体情况。著名的PREP里面有一个Stresses that girls experience are more likely to result in depression than are those boys experience. 因为than 前面是一个名词depression,所以要补上be动词。

 我认为这题的重点在于比较对象。national average 和Americans “人”不对称。同样prep也有一个题，an average global warming.../a global warming that average.Average 这个词既是名词又是形容词，出现在比较对象的对等上面很Tricky.

[此贴子已经被作者于2007-5-15 11:54:35编辑过]

lisony

以下是引用alicfine在2007-5-15 11:53:00的发言：

这道题我也错了，但是我不大同意ls的观点.

A,Americans of...were  as likely as the national average was

B,as the average American to be self-employed

Be 动词是否需要省略要看具体情况。著名的PREP里面有一个Stresses that girls experience are more likely to result in depression than are those boys experience. 因为than 前面是一个名词depression,所以要补上be动词。

 我认为这题的重点在于比较对象。national average 和Americans “人”不对称。同样prep也有一个题，an average global warming.../a global warming that average.Average 这个词既是名词又是形容词，出现在比较对象的对等上面很Tricky.

非常详细，同意！！

springsound

以下是引用alicfine在2007-5-15 11:53:00的发言：

这道题我也错了，但是我不大同意ls的观点.

A,Americans of...were  as likely as the national average was

B,as the average American to be self-employed

Be 动词是否需要省略要看具体情况。著名的PREP里面有一个Stresses that girls experience are more likely to result in depression than are those boys experience. 因为than 前面是一个名词depression,所以要补上be动词。

 我认为这题的重点在于比较对象。national average 和Americans “人”不对称。同样prep也有一个题，an average global warming.../a global warming that average.Average 这个词既是名词又是形容词，出现在比较对象的对等上面很Tricky.

 

那么象本题A项这样, 前面两个BE动词的单复数形式不同, 是不是就不应该省略呢?

Krystal_Wang

比较结构里的东东什么时候可以省略，什么时候不能省略，我始终没有搞清楚，还有3天就要考了，唉唉～～

smartsky11

12