Oxford vs HKUST: Oxford is no good

newboyss

Sussman, O., 'Economic Growth with Standardized Contracts', European Economic Review, Vol.43:9, 1999, pp.1797-1818.

Suarez, J. & Sussman, O., 'Financial Distress and the Business Cycle', Oxford Review of Economic Policy, Vol.15:3, 1999, pp.39-51.

Sussman, O., 'Language and Contract', Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics, Vol.154:2, 1998, pp.384-405.

Suarez, J. & Sussman, O., 'Endogenous Cycles in a Stiglitz-Weiss Economy', Journal of Economic Theory, Vol.76:1, 1997, pp.47-71.

Roell, A. & Sussman, O., 'Stabilization', European Economic Review, Vol.41:2, 1997, pp.279-293.

newboyss

"Generic Determinacy and Money Non-Neutrality of International Monetary Equilibria", Journal of Mathematical Economics, forthcoming, 2007.

“Banks, Relative Performance, and Sequential Contagion”, (with S. Bhattacharya, C.A.E. Goodhart and P. Sunirand), Economic Theory, forthcoming , 2007

"Evaluation of Macroeconomic Models for Financial Stability Analysis", (with G. Bardsen and K-G. Lindquist), Journal of World Economics Review, forthcoming, 2007.

"Towards a Measure of Financial Fragility", (with O. Aspachs, C.A.E. Goodhart and L. Zicchino), Annals of Finance, 3(1), 37-74, 2007,

"Financial Stability: Theory and Applications", (with C.A.E. Goodhart),  Annals of Finance, 3(1), 1-5, 2007,

“A Model to Analyse Financial Fragility”, (with C.A.E. Goodhart and P. Sunirand), Economic Theory , v. 27. pp. 107-142, 2006.

“ A Time Series Analysis of Financial Fragility in the UK Banking System”, (with C.A.E. Goodhart and P. Sunirand), Annals of Finance , Volume 2, Nr. 1, pp. 1-21, 2006 .

“A Risk Assessment Model for Banks”, (with C.A.E. Goodhart and P. Sunirand), Annals of Finance , Volume 1, Nr. 2, pp. 197-224, January 2005.

“Procyclicality and the New Basel Accord – Banks' Choice of Loan Rating System”, (with E. Catarineu-Rabell and P. Jackson), Economic Theory , v.26. Nr.3, pp. 537-557, 2005.

“A Model to Analyse Financial Fragility: Applications”, (with C.A.E. Goodhart and P. Sunirand), Journal of Financial Stability , Volume 1, 1:1-35, 2004.

“The Influence of the Olympic Spirit to the Development of Modern Capital and Financial Markets”, IDISEEP 1 st Conference Series , Proceedings, 2004.

“Equilibrium Analysis, Banking, Contagion and Financial Fragility”, Bank of England W.P. Series #175, 2003. (Also, Greek Economic Review , Volume 23(1), 2004).

“Equilibrium Analysis, Banking, and Financial Instability”, Journal of Mathematical Economics , Volume 39, Issues 5-6, pp. 619-655, July 2003.

“E-Barter vs. Fiat Money: Will Central Banks Survive?” (with F. Capie and G. Wood), Bank of England W.P. Series #197, 2003. (Also, in Essays in Economics in Honour of T. Benos. Edited by E. Drandakis, D. Glykopantis, and G Stamatis. Kritiki, forthcoming, 2007).

“ ΕΥΡΩ : Προκλήσεις και Προοπτικές ”, (in Greek) Pemptousia , February 2003.

“International Finance in General Equilibrium”, (with J. Geanakoplos), Ricerche Economiche , 56, pp. 85-142, 2002.

“A Strategic Market Game with Seigniorage Costs of Fiat Money”, (with M. Shubik), Economic Theory , v.19. Nr.1, 2002.

“Option Values and Endogenous Uncertainty in ESOPs, MBOs and Asset-Backed Loans”, (with G. Chichilnisky and G.M. Heal), Economics Letters , 48, 1995.

“A Strategic Market Game with a Mutual Bank with Fractional Reserves and Redemption in Gold”, (with M. Shubik), Journal of Economics v.55. Nr 2, 1992.

Appendix of “The Transactions Cost of Money”, by M. Shubik and S. Yao , Mathematical Social Sciences , 20, 1990.

newboyss

van Bommel, J., & Vermaelen, T., 'Post-IPO capital expenditures and market feedback', Journal of Banking and Finance, Vol.27, 2003, pp.275-305.

van Bommel, J., 'Rumors', Journal of Finance, Vol.58, 2003, pp.1499-1520.

van Bommel, J., 'Messages from Market to Management: the Case of IPOs', Journal of Corporate Finance, Vol.8, 2002, pp.123-138.

newboyss

Vulkan, N., & Priest, C., 'Automated Trading in Agents-based Markets for Communication Bandwidth', forthcoming International Journal of Electronic Commerce, 2004.

Hurkens, S., & Vulkan, N., 'Free Entry does not Imply Zero Profits', forthcoming Economic Letters, 2004.

Scaramozzino, P., & Vulkan, N., 'Uncertainty and Endogenous Selection of Macroeconomics Equilibrium', forthcoming Metroeconomica, 2004.

Vulkan, N., 'Strategic design of mobile agents', The Artificial Intelligence Magazine, 2002.

Vulkan, N., 'Equilibria for Automated Negotiations', Games and Economic Behavior, Vol.35:1/2, 2001, pp.339-348.

Vulkan, N., & Hurkens, S., 'Information Acquisition and Entry', Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, Vol.44:4, 2001, pp.467-479.

Vulkan, N. et al., 'A multidisciplinary perspective on multi-agent systems', Knowledge Engineering Review, Vol.15:3, 2000, pp.293-301.

Vulkan, N., 'An economist's perspective on probability matching', Journal of Economic Surveys, Vol.14:1, 2000, pp.101-118.

Vulkan, N., 'Efficient mechanism for service allocation in multiagent systems', Decision Support Systems, Vol.28:1-2, 2000, pp.5-19.

Vulkan, N., 'Agents in E-Commerce', Wirtschaftspolitische Blatter, Vol.5, 1999, pp.467-473.

Vulkan, N, & Binmore, K., 'Applying game theory to automated negotiation', Netonomics, Vol.1, 1999, pp.1-10.

Vulkan, N., 'Economic implications of agent technology and e-commerce', The Economic Journal, Vol.109:453, 1999, pp.67-90.

newboyss

The total number of top publications from Oxford Finance Department is 16. at HKUST, its area chair Kalok Chan publishes more than the whole Oxford department in terms of top publications. Kalok Chan's brother, KC chan, the dean at HKUST is even better. another guy, Yuseek Chan is also very good.

That is whey I say Oxford cannot compare with HKUST.

However, LBS is much better than HKUST

[此贴子已经被作者于2007-3-14 3:45:56编辑过]

modern

同一篇文  我也得在這邊回應一番:

我比較想了解newboyss對於" good business school"的定義

列出attributes之後

是用Lexicographic model

還是conjunctive or disconjunctive

去評價呢? 

另外  以單一accounting dep的A+期刊論文數  引用數等  純objective指標去判定  會不會失准呢?  即便是加上其他不同department的A+期刊論文數作為 benchmark之一  這樣就ok了嘛

是否要考量subjective benchmarks?  例如學生反應  ?  或是更多其他的objective benchmarks呢?

正如很多學生去之前心中的疑問

MBA學生需要的是什麼  難道是學術排名？ 是教授的出版數字？ 

A+論文數目

對於學生進步程度的co-relation是多少?
對於學生找好工作的co-relation又是多少? 
對於學生對學校的向心力  對MBA program滿意程度 的corelation 又是多少?

我們得好好想出這其中的奧妙  您說是嗎?

newboyss

Certainly, there are many ways to classify business schools and you have to make a judgement after you consider the following attributes:

1. faculty strength

2. placement record,

3. alumni network

4. social recognition.

It is hard for me to collect all the data. the data I provided is only part of the story and can be used as a signal for the quality of the program. However, what I want to point out here is that you have to do some research before you make your final conclusion. This decision has to be made by yourself. What I have done here is my own ranking based on my own preference. The problem for many Chinese students is that they do not know much and simply assume that Oxford is better than HKUST. When you challenge them to ask why and they cannot come up with any reasonable support for their judgement.