长江中欧教授大比拼: 小结

supportwu

I support zhenhaowu's view. LZ's conclusion is not reliable for the following reasons:

1. Sample size is too small. For example, there are only two accounting faculties in CEIBS. How conclusive can such a comparison be?

2. LZ is comparing apples with oranges.  CKGSB faculties are are full professors while CEIBS have assistant, associate and full professors. Naturally, full professors tend to have more impact than assistant professors.

3. LZ is comparing samples with unequal size. CKGSB has 20 some faculties and CEIBS has 30 some faculties. It is likely that as CKGSB expands it will have to attract faculties of less caliber and its research impact will decline as well.

4. As zhenhaowu pointed out, the research is not independent and  thus is subject to selection bias. It is easy to see that someone from CKGSB is more likely to report results favorable to CKGSB and keep quiet about negative information.

newboyss

我提供一下方法, 申请人可自己使用.此方法可靠性多大, 请各位自己判断.

打开google.com, 可见以下链接

网页    图片    资讯    论坛    更多 »

打开 更多 » 可见以下链接

Google 服务

	网页搜索         搜索80多亿网页			网页搜索特色         计算器、股票查询、英汉互译等搜索小窍门
	新闻         阅读、搜索新闻			地图         查询地址、捜索周边和规划路线
	新闻快讯         定制实时新闻，直接发至邮箱			大学搜索         搜索特定大学的网站
	论坛         交流、讨论和分享			学术搜索         搜索学术文章
	网页目录         按主题浏览各类网站			Google 实验室         各种创意与想法、产品模型和试验
	图片          搜索超过10亿张图片 打开  学术搜索              搜索学术文章 可见以下链接                学术高级搜索 学术搜索使用偏好 学术搜索帮助 搜索所有网页搜索所有中文网页搜索简体中文网页 站在巨人的肩膀上 打入教授名字即可搜索. 我们可以试试Harvard's Michael Porter in strategy [引用] ‘What is Strategy? ’ M Porter - Harvard Business Review, 1996               被引用次数：1260 - 网页搜索 - 图书馆搜索              [DOC] How information gives you competitive advantage ME Porter, VE Millar - Harvard Business Review, 1985 - classwork.busadm.mu.edu               The authors of this article provide a useful framework for analyzing the strategic significance of the new information technology. They show how and why the technology is changing the way companies operate internally as well as altering the relationships among companies and their suppliers, ...               被引用次数：1134 - 相关文章 - HTML 版 - 网页搜索              Toward a New Conception of the Environment-Competitiveness Relationship ME Porter, C van der Linde - The Journal of Economic Perspectives, 1995 - ideas.repec.org               Accepting a fixed trade-off between environmental regulation and competitiveness unnecessarily raises costs and slows down environmental progress. Studies finding high environmental compliance costs have traditionally focused on static cost impacts, ignoring any offsetting productivity ...               被引用次数：702 - 相关文章 - 网页快照 - 网页搜索 - 图书馆搜索 Chicago's Eugene Fama in finance Common risk factors in the returns on stocks and bonds - 每组 4 个 » EF Fama, KR French - Journal of Financial Economics, 1993 - wiwi.uni-frankfurt.de                This paper identities five common risk factors in the returns on stocks and bonds. There are three stock-market factors: an overall market factor and factors related to firm size and book-to-market equity. There are two bond-market factors. related to maturity and default risks. Stock returns ...                被引用次数：1946 - 相关文章 - www.wiwi.uni-frankfurt.de/kolleg/classes/spring_05/asset_pricing/papers/famafrench93.pdf+eugene+fama+" target="nw">HTML 版 - 网页搜索               Separation of Ownership and Control - 每组 14 个 » EF Fama, MC Jensen - Journal of Law and Economics, 1983 - JSTOR                302 THE JOURNAL OF LAW AND ECONOMICS management and risk bearing but also because of an effective common approach to controlling the agency problems caused by separation of decision and risk-bearing functions. In particular, our hypothesis is that the contract structures of all of ...                被引用次数：1886 - 相关文章 - 网页搜索 - 图书馆搜索               Efficient Capital Markets: A Review of Theory and Empirical Work EF Fama - The Journal of Finance, 1970 - ideas.repec.org                If you experience problems downloading a file, check if you have the proper application to view it first. Information about this may be contained in the File-Format links below. In case of further problems read the IDEAS help file. Note that these files are not on the IDEAS site. Please be ...                被引用次数：1688 - 相关文章 - 网页快照 - 网页搜索

Mit's Birger Wernerfelt in marketing

The resource-based view of the firm: ten years after
B WERNERFELT - Strategic management journal, 1995 - cat.inist.fr
   
The resource-based view of the firm: ten years after. B
   WERNERFELT Strategic management
journal 16:33, 171-174, Wiley, 1995. The article reflects on the diffusion of the
«resource-based view of the firm» into academic and practitioner thought ...
   
被引用次数：2932 - 相关文章 - 网页搜索 - 图书馆搜索
  

[引用] The link between resources and type of diversification: Theory and evidence
S Chatterjee, B Wernerfelt - Strategic Management Journal, 1991
   
被引用次数：220 - 相关文章 - 网页搜索
  

[引用] Determinants of firm performance: the relative importance of economic and organizational factors
GS Hansen, B Wernerfelt - Strategic Management Journal, 1989
   
被引用次数：208 - 相关文章 - 网页搜索

Arizona state's James Ohlson in accounting

Earnings, book values, and dividends in equity valuation - 每组 4 个 »
JA Ohlson - Contemporary Accounting Research, 1995 - credit.wharton.upenn.edu
    
Page 1. Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction
prohibited without permission. Earnings, book values, and dividends in equity valuation
Ohlson, James A Contemporary Accounting Research; Spring 1995; 11, 2; ABI ...
    
被引用次数：721 - 相关文章 - HTML 版 - 网页搜索
   

Financial Ratios and the Probabilistic Prediction of Bankruptcy
JA Ohlson - Journal of Accounting Research, 1980 - JSTOR
    
110 JOURNAL OF ACCOUNTING RESEARCH, SPRING 1980 third study, by Altman, Haldeman, and Narayanan [1977], which "up-
dates" the original Altman [1968] study, basically considers data from the period 1969 to 1975. Their sample was based
on fifty-three failed firms and about the same number ...
    
被引用次数：414 - 相关文章 - 网页搜索
   

[引用] Valuation and Clean Surplus Accounting for Operating and Financial Activities
G Feltham, JA Ohlson - Contemporary Accounting Research, 1995
    
被引用次数：380 - n6MgHv6EeoJ:scholar.google.com/" target="nw">相关文章 - 网页搜索 
  

Stanford's Hau Lee in Operations Management

Information Distortion in a Supply Chain: The Bullwhip Effect - 每组 6 个 »
HL Lee, V Padmanabhan, S Whang - Management Science, 1997 - extenza-eps.com
    
Department of Industrial Engineering and Engineering Management, Stanford University, Stanford, California 94305 V.
Padmanabhan 2 , Seungjin Whang Graduate School of Business, Stanford University, Stanford, California 94305 C onsider a
series of companies in a supply chain, each of whom ...
    
被引用次数：835 - 相关文章 - 网页搜索
   

The bullwhip effect in supply chains - 每组 8 个 »
HL Lee, V Padmanabhan, S Whang - Sloan Management Review, 1997 - www-ifl.mach.uni-karlsruhe.de
    
Abstract: The bullwhip effect occurs when the demand order variabilities in the supply chain are amplified as they moved
up the supply chain. Distorted information from one end of a supply chain to the other can lead to tremendous
inefficiencies. Companies can effectively counteract ...
    
被引用次数：595 - 相关文章 - HTML 版 - 网页搜索
   

The Value of Information Sharing in a Two-Level Supply Chain - 每组 9 个 »
HL Lee, KC So, CS Tang - Management Science, 2000 - extenza-eps.com
    
M any companies have embarked on initiatives that enable more demand information sharing between retailers and their
upstream suppliers. While the literature on such initiatives in the business press is proliferating, it is not clear how
one can quantify the benefits of these initiatives and ...
    
被引用次数：266 - 相关文章 - 网页搜索
 

stanford's Eisenhardt, KM  in management 

Building Theories from Case Study Research - 每组 2 个 »
KM Eisenhardt - The Academy of Management Review, 1989 - bebas.vlsm.org
   
Page 1. Building Theories From Case Study Research Kathleen M. Eisenhardt Academy
of Management Review Oct 1989 p. 532-550 Page 2. Latar Belakang Paper • Masih ada
ketidakjelasan mengenai proses pembentukan teori dari kasus yang ada, khususnya ...
   
被引用次数：2905 - 35sy6uQgokJ:scholar.google.com/" target="nw">相关文章 - 35sy6uQgokJ:bebas.vlsm.org/v06/Kuliah/Seminar-MIS/2004/63/63_08_AMR-14-4-1989-Eisenhardt-presentasi.pdf+academy+of+management+author:k-eisenhardt" target="nw">HTML 版 - 网页搜索
  

[引用] Agency Theory: An Assessment and Review
KM Eisenhardt - The Academy of Management Review, 1989 - Academy of Management
   
被引用次数：937 - 相关文章 - 网页搜索
  

Product Development: Past Research, Present Findings, and Future Directions
SL Brown, KM Eisenhardt - The Academy of Management Review, 1995 - JSTOR
   
1995 Brown and Eisenhardt 377 How Japanese compamlies learn cnd unlearn. In RH Hayes, K. Clark, & Lorenz (Eds.), The
uneasy alliance: Managing the productivity-technology dilemma: 337-375. Boston: Harvard Business School Press. Joyce, WF
1986. Matrix organizations: A social experiment. ...
   
被引用次数：572 - 相关文章 - 网页搜索
  

Stanford's David Kreps in economics

[引用] Martingales and arbitrage in multiperiod securities markets
JM Harrison, D Kreps - Journal of Economic Theory, 1979
   
被引用次数：1038 - alRJ8GcXXkJ:scholar.google.com/" target="nw">相关文章 - 网页搜索
  

[引用] Corporate Culture and Economic Theory
DM Kreps - Perspectives on Positive Political Economy, 1990 - Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
   
被引用次数：749 - 相关文章 - 网页搜索
  

Reputation and Imperfect Information - 每组 4 个 »
D Kreps, R Wilson - Journal of Economic Theory, 1982 - polisci.ucsd.edu
   
A common observation in the informal literature of economics (and elsewhere) is that in multistage “games,” players
may seek early in the game to acquire a reputation for being “tough” or “benevolent” or something else. But this
phenomenon is not observed in some formal ...
   
被引用次数：681 - 相关文章 - www.polisci.ucsd.edu/~bslantch/courses/pdf/kreps-jet1982v27n2.pdf+d+kreps" target="nw">HTML 版 - 网页搜索
  

[此贴子已经被作者于2006-11-27 8:55:15编辑过]

DongFeng

 最近很多新马甲。。。

我建议初次上CD发贴的人需要慎思而言（尤其是刚刚注册且只有1片文章的发言人），以免彼此引起不必要的猜疑。

newboyss 至今身份不明（调查过，但没人知道），但治学态度严谨，至少说话不是空穴来风，有依有据。是我们这些人值得学习的。。。

[此贴子已经被作者于2006-11-27 9:33:18编辑过]

newboyss

James Ohlson (valuation model), David Kreps (game theory), Eugene Fama (efficienty market), Katherine Eisenhardt (agency issues), Hau Lee (supply chain), Birger Wernerfelt (resource based theory of firm), Michael Porter (5 core competitive force) 都是各自领域的大牛.用我的影响度量也显示了他们的不一样.当然, 这个度量只能用作参考,不能绝对化.大家有兴趣的话可以把亚洲的学校一一比较: HKUST, HKU, CUHK, NSU, Korea, Yongsei, NUS, SMU, Nanyang, Taipei, CEIBS, CKGSB, Tsinghua, Beida, Fudan, Jiaoda

James_007

看了长江和中欧，香港科技大学等的比较，

结论终于出来了：

长江是亚洲最好的商学院！！！

鉴定完毕, 楼主可以休息一下了，不用隔两三天就发一个帖子，发的满世界都是，

用长江把所有商学院都比下去，你累不累啊？

yorkatlas

以下是引用James_007在2006-11-28 12:16:00的发言：

看了长江和中欧，香港科技大学等的比较，

结论终于出来了：

长江是亚洲最好的商学院！！！

鉴定完毕, 楼主可以休息一下了，不用隔两三天就发一个帖子，发的满世界都是，

用长江把所有商学院都比下去，你累不累啊？

伤肝呀

DongFeng

楼主只是做了个统计，反正方法都告诉大家了，信与不信，服与不服，每个人都自己判断好啦。。。

但其他人千万别把矛头对准某个学校，这样容易伤和气的。。。

大棒锤

大家在夸你们呢。不要过谦了。

newboyss

争论问题有以下几种方式：

1，实证：用大量的数据作分析，支持自己的观点。我认为这是最好的

2，逻辑论证：用假设和逻辑推导， 阐明自己的观点。这方法其次

3，比喻：用类比，讲故事，支撑自己的观点。中国的传统方法。 这方法最糟糕。类比往往不恰当， 讲故 事会走极端。但受大众欢迎因为容易懂。

4，没有实证，没有论证， 也不会讲故事作比喻， 那怎么办？拳头，棍棒，让对方闭嘴。

诸位喜欢什么方式？

dannywhw

大家在争什么?我们的资源是如此的有限,争得头破血流也只有这么一点啊.

1.GOOGOLE也不是万能的,搜索派名不就是用来卖的吗?

2.相同的教授面对不同的学生,教的东西也会很不相同.我们STRATEGIC COMMUNICATION的老头,在我们SECTION上谈笑风生,而在另一个SECTION却大发雷霆,怎么说?可能就是碰巧谁踩了他尾巴了.

3.就是教得一模一样,吸收的就一样吗?