请教牛人share with 用法 885 Section A-11

cxj

Marketing researchers have found that, because many residents of the Southeast do not share the same ethnic heritage as Northeasterners, the two varieties of commercially prepared coleslaw most popular in New York City and Boston are virtually ignored by consumers in Richmond and Raleigh.
(A) because many residents of the Southeast do not share the same ethnic heritage as
(B) because many residents of the Southeast do not share the same ethnic heritage with
(C) because many residents of the Southeast do not have the same ethnic heritage as
(D) due to many residents of the Southeast not sharing the same ethnic heritage with
(E) whereas many residents of the Southeast do not share the same ethnic heritage as
疑问1： 答案 C   这里The same...as  是否应该加 do  or have
疑问2： B为什么?同 C 有什么区别？
Thanks a million!

[此贴子已经被作者于2003-10-18 9:40:08编辑过]

yzlinlin

我觉得这题是一道比较好的寻找最佳答案的题。

B不如C，是因为B中share和the same的同时使用会在介词使用上产生矛盾(share with, the same as)，难以两全。C用have 很巧妙地回避了这个矛盾。

cxj

Thanks a lot!

wwwhahchn

以下是引用yzlinlin在2003-10-19 8:29:00的发言：
我觉得这题是一道比较好的寻找最佳答案的题。

B不如C，是因为B中share和the same的同时使用会在介词使用上产生矛盾(share with, the same as)，难以两全。C用have 很巧妙地回避了这个矛盾。

请问，the same不能单独用吗？后面一定要跟as？不能单纯地看成share sth. with sb.？

C的as后面不用加do吗？？

ogram

反对2楼，支持4楼

C选项把ethnic heritage 同Northeasterners 放在一起作比较，范了严重错误。另外，在GMAT语法中，have在表示“拥有”的意思时，往往是接具体名词，如have a book, have a car等等，而不接heritage之类的抽象名词

B选项是可以接受的

share 至少有两种用法，一种是X and Y share sth.,另一种是X share sth. with Y.

B选项用的是后一种用法。same 放在这里只是起强调作用，跟the same as 的固定搭配无关

为什么我们提到same 的时候，非要把它跟as扯在一起呢？好像same离了as 就活不成了。国内的英文教育真是误人不浅啊

另外，我可以看出来，大家在讨论时，都是先假定参考答案的绝对权威性，然后想方设法找出与参考答案不符的选项中的漏洞

可是我想知道的是，出了OG提供的答案之外，其他参考答案是否也都出自ETS？或是由新东方老师自己提供的？如果属于后者的情况，那么就不该迷信参考答案。就连ETS自己有时都会出一些昏题

advantage

我也对as后没有动词或助动词表示强烈的怀疑

weichenli

所以这题的正确答案应该是??

大家讨论讨论吧!

weichenli

up up!!! either b or c?

weichenli

以下是引用cxj在2003-10-17 11:30:00的发言：
Marketing researchers have found that, because many residents of the Southeast do not share the same ethnic heritage as Northeasterners, the two varieties of commercially prepared coleslaw most popular in New York City and Boston are virtually ignored by consumers in Richmond and Raleigh.
(A) because many residents of the Southeast do not share the same ethnic heritage as
(B) because many residents of the Southeast do not share the same ethnic heritage with
(C) because many residents of the Southeast do not have the same ethnic heritage as
(D) due to many residents of the Southeast not sharing the same ethnic heritage with
(E) whereas many residents of the Southeast do not share the same ethnic heritage as
疑问1： 答案 C   这里The same...as  是否应该加 do  or have
疑问2： B为什么?同 C 有什么区别？
Thanks a million!

我覺得答案是B!

這是我的理由!

I share the same book as you. 如果AS 後面沒有補出動詞, 此句會有兩種可能性

1. I 跟 YOU 比

2. Book 跟 you 比 --->OG 說的dangling, 兩個名詞出現, 不清楚

所以本提的 the same as 跟 share with 的取捨上, 把 the same as 放棄掉因為邏輯上不清, 而

I share the same cake with you. 我跟你分同一個蛋糕 是合理的!

有人假設這裡是the same ethic heritage 的比較, 而意思上不能只同一個而是個人的 ethinic heritage, 我想這個說法並不是那麼的絕對, 就像我蛋糕的例子一樣, 是可行的!

大家說說看吧!

tigerzheng

同意B。

如果选C，则意思是东南部的人不SHARE WITH 同一个传统，象东北部的人一样（不SHARE WITH同一个传统）。而从句子的后半部看，应该是东南部的人和东北部的人并不SHARE WITH同一个传统，才有New York City and Boston 和Richmond and Raleigh的对比。

请大家讨论！