[讨论]OG11th-105

dengrong7674

我感觉在非限定定语从句中WHICH优先就近指代，并且优先指代中心词，请牛牛指正

cccccc0

我想问B选项中的地解释second modifier (having...)acctually modifies the first modifier.

我觉得此时的having 应该是修饰句子的主语a technology.

因为OG11-102解释在说B选项时说道

B)In her book illustrations, carefuuly coordinating them with her narratives, Beatrix Potter

B的解释Phrase carefully coordinating...illogically modifies the noun that immediately precedes it (book illustrations)otter, not the illustrations, did the coordinating; awkward and unclear.

请大牛们解释下阿

cccccc0

自己upupupupupupoupupupupupup

叽里咕噜

以下是引用FlowerJay在2006-9-10 2:38:00的发言：
小发表一下意见。。。
xxxx1 , xxxx2 , which.....     none restrictive修饰的应该是他之前的语法单元，这里面的which，就是修饰的xxxx2 而不能跳跃修饰xxxx1
在同一个语法单元里面比如说 X of Y, which ，  这里面which应该修饰的是X而不是Y，因为X是主词，Y是副词。 这就是很多选项 X of Y,which，如果which逻辑指向Y的话，一般被归类成awkard。。。
大家觉得make sense么

我印象中，好几个大N说过，X of Y, which...里面的which并不是固定地修饰X或者Y, 而是两者都有可能，要根据具体句子逻辑意思判断。有待继续探讨～

jcjc0602

到底这道题的A的which不修饰emission啊？

williamjin

以下是引用sunnysmell在2006-6-22 3:56:00的发言：

同问，为什么OG说A,which refers to a technique; C, which refers to emission
A. Originally developed for detecting air pollutants, a technique called proton-induced x-ray emission, which can quickly analyze ...

C. A technique originally developed for detecting air pollutants, called proton-induced x-ray emission, which can quickly analyze ...

以下是引用zombie在2006-8-15 1:40:00的发言：

除了楼上的问题，为什么Called proton-induced X-ray emission should be placed next to a technique ？？？

再问!

lsw

以下是引用布瓜丫丫在2006-8-14 18:29:00的发言：

还是有同样的困惑，那位高手能不能给解释一下呢？

以下是引用sunnysmell在2006-6-22 3:56:00的发言：

同问，为什么OG说A,which refers to a technique; C, which refers to emission
A. Originally developed for detecting air pollutants, a technique called proton-induced x-ray emission, which can quickly analyze ...

C. A technique originally developed for detecting air pollutants, called proton-induced x-ray emission, which can quickly analyze ...

which修饰的是最近的一个词，我好像在哪道题中看到过这样的解释，具体记不起来了。

主要是在c中，容易引起歧义，句子表达就不清晰了。

俺觉得，gmat的语法更强调哪个答案更好，而不是简单的正确与否。

[此贴子已经被作者于2006-12-18 5:38:14编辑过]

Iawfy

我觉得Ａ中前边的成分和后边的成分都是修饰主语a technique，所以which应该优先指代句子主语
而Ｃ中which是想指代a technique，只是此时主语被放在了句首，离which太远，有指代不清的问题，所以就指代离它最近的emission
欢迎继续讨论

lsw

以下是引用Iawfy在2006-12-18 6:29:00的发言：
而Ｃ中which是想指代a technique，只是此时主语被放在了句首，离which太远，有指代不清的问题，所以就指代离它最近的emission

I agree.

Iawfy

再补充一点就是分析一下句子逻辑
究竟是technique来analyze呢，还是x-ray emission来analyze，所以更可以确定which是指代technique的