有人申请Yale吗？

shouyang12

以下是引用zhang206在2005-11-17 3:25:00的发言：

no to stanford but definitely yes to wharton.

it's a fact. just look at the people at all the PE firms, you will understand.

Harvard and stanford (esp. Harvard) stand out from the rest, at least in the US.

stanford和wharton是完全不同的两各个风格

wharton比stanford更注重内在的东西

相信wharton风格潜力更大

各人认为wharton和HBS差不多

stanford还稍逊点

[此贴子已经被作者于2005-11-17 5:21:48编辑过]

izone

All the three should be good enough to prep you to go anywhere.



H is the good place to go if you want to  do PE in US.  But
in reality, most of those HBS students went to PE are previously
analysts of PE firms.  You will often see 50% of a firm is from
HBS.



That said, being in HBS alone won't help much.  Even you're from
McK or Goldman, you don't stand much chance there because there are 50
others at HBS with same background.  



Anyway, fully agree that HBS is a great school but I don't think placement in PE means much to ordinary students.





Stanford should be the right place for VC guys, I guess.  

dashasha

以下是引用izone在2005-11-17 3:13:00的发言：
Just my 2 cents:


Yale and Yale SOM are very friendly to Chinese.  The protest you
heard is because someone is trying to get media coverage for other
reasons.


BTW, I have Chinese friends in other top bschools, most of which are of
"higher rank".  From what I heard and saw, Yale is not inferior by
any means, if not better.

同意。很多学校都有学生被退的事情发生，不过yale这件闹的大家都知道了而已。

dashasha

以下是引用zhang206在2005-11-17 3:25:00的发言：

no to stanford but definitely yes to wharton.

it's a fact. just look at the people at all the PE firms, you will understand.

Harvard and stanford (esp. Harvard) stand out from the rest, at least in the US.

不太同意。单从PE里的人的表现就能下这样的结论啊，当然，你可以说PE很难进，呵呵。其实呢，我觉得这些个学校（包括其他的TOP 15）水平都差不多啦，学生素质也是看个人。硬要区分学校之间高下，实在没必要而且也不太能够客观。个人观点，豁出去了，烂西红柿臭鸡蛋尽管来。

dashasha

以下是引用shouyang12在2005-11-17 5:15:00的发言：

stanford和wharton是完全不同的两各个风格

wharton比stanford更注重内在的东西

相信wharton风格潜力更大

各人认为wharton和HBS差不多

stanford还稍逊点

wharton比stanford更注重内在？哪儿得来的结论啊？

shouyang12

以下是引用dashasha在2005-11-17 7:02:00的发言：

wharton比stanford更注重内在？哪儿得来的结论啊？

想讨论加我QQ:418511985

nnasa

说老实话，商学院排名纠纷太多。有人从学术角度，有人从投资角度，还有人从大众名气角度。不能一概而论。如果真的要从HBS和wharton及分出个你死我活的话，估计CD forum的服务器会很快需要升级。关于升级服务器，我倒是可以给出很cost-effective的建议。 呵呵

cheeyong

同意。不要去争哪个学校最好，因为排名本来就是很柔性的东西，不是竞技体育，你跑的比别人快，你就是第一。所以，大家只要在top的学校里面选择你最喜欢的就可以了，哪个更好一点本来就是仁者见仁，智者见智的。没有最好的，只有你最喜欢的和最合适的。

cn_sumin

I am applying YALE.

dashasha

以下是引用shouyang12在2005-11-17 8:00:00的发言：

想讨论加我QQ:418511985

我不会用QQ啊，虽然很想听听您的高见。