OG18 694 求NN分析OG解释

May97

694. In the seventh century B.C., the Roman alphabet was adapted from the Etruscan alphabet, which in turn had been adapted in the previous century from a western Greek alphabet, which itself had been adapted earlier in the same century from the Phoenician alphabet.
(A) which itself had been adapted earlier
(B) adapting itself earlier
(C) itself being adapted earlier
(D) having been earlier adapted itself
(E) earlier itself having been adapted

B： The present participle could be used for an event that was simultaneous with, or part of, the event mentioned before the underlined portion.
之前好像有看过Ron 对participle使用的时态问题进行解释，但是忘记在哪里了，有小伙伴记得可以帮忙贴出来吗？

D： Without commas around itself, the pronoun appears to be reflexive. The combination of passive and reflexive then makes no sense. If itself is intended simply for emphasis, rather than as a reflexive pronoun, it would be preferable, in this context, to set it off with commas.
og想表达的是：如果itself表示的是强调，就需要用逗号隔开？？总感觉怪怪的，求nn解释

danyuchn

我想Ron應該講的是：這種放在句尾作為adverb modifer的particle phrase時間點不能落在主要句之前。因為公用表(1) 結果 (2) 闡述說明細節。要馬是同時要馬是之後，不會是之前。之前的話要放在句首。

xiyuzisu

我看了一下我自己的笔记：
1.itself是反身代词，反身代词不能独立做主语，只能做主语的同位语（A选项）
2.这道题有两个大问题：
首先是ing问题，你看到ing就找到主语，看是不是修饰主语，这里很明显它想修饰的是前面那个单词而不是主语，所以BD错误
其次是时态，这里要用过去完成时，所以只有A正确

我也是以OG解释为主，但是它解释的不好理解的时候，就找找自己能接受的解释

blowdy

xiyuzisu 发表于 2018-4-21 21:16
我看了一下我自己的笔记：
1.itself是反身代词，反身代词不能独立做主语，只能做主语的同位语（A选项）
2. ...

同意！               

梦季

看一下！               

dyjzcy12

danyuchn 发表于 2018-4-4 01:27
我想Ron應該講的是：這種放在句尾作為adverb modifer的particle phrase時間點不能落在主要句之前。因為公用 ...

Mark一下！