关于consider 后面能不能加as的问题——OG17-805

三磷酸腺苷

OG2017-805题
Although she was considered among her contemporaries to be the better poet than her husband, later Elizabeth Barrett Browning was overshadowed by his success.         
(A) Although she was considered among her contemporaries to be the better poet than her husband, later Elizabeth Barrett Browning was overshadowed by his success.
(B) Although Elizabeth Barrett Browning was considered among her contemporaries as a better poet than her husband, she was later overshadowed by his success.
(C) Later overshadowed by the success of her husband, Elizabeth Barrett Browning poetry had been considered among her contemporaries to be better than that of her husband.
(D) Although Elizabeth Barrett Browning`s success was later overshadowed by that of her husband, among her contemporaries she was considered the better poet.
(E) Elizabeth Barrett Browning`s poetry was considered among her contemporaries as better than her husband, but her success was later overshadowed by his


正确答案是D。

明白为啥其他四个选项是错的，但是不太清楚B选项里面的 considered... as问题：
有的地方说可以用consider A as B 也可以用consider A B，但是也看到有的地方说只能用consider A B。

OG的解析说这里的as会引发歧义而且awkward，说它unnecessarily creates a pontential misleading (she was considered to be among her contemporaries)。
没有太懂解析中这个pontential meaning是什么意思，也不太懂在这道题中是可以有as也可以没有，还是不能有as。
（用不用as和这里用的consider是considered有关系么？）

求大大解救qwq

CooKieBell

我个人做过的题里面似乎没有正确答案里包含consider A as B的，曼哈顿SC89页Idiom上也得也是consider X Y，所以我个人感觉就是看到consider X as Y的先别马上一票否决，看看别的答案，如果别的答案有更好的，那就选别的，如果其他四个明显都是错的那就选这个吧

Hannah-luo

A选项：当consider意为“看作（regard as）”时，只能用consider A B，而不能用consider A to be B。当consider意为“认为”时，只能用consider A to be B而不能用consider A B。看起来是在考查语法，实则不然，这背后是在考查考生的逻辑推理能力。在原理上近似于不定式和名词的区别。如果在consider的宾语和宾语的补足语间添加to be，则to be B就变成了不定式短语。我们知道，当consider表示“看作”时，其约束力较弱。看作是一种客观的说法，对“A是B”这个事件没有主观的控制。但当consider表示“认为，以为”时，显然，其约束力较强。因为“认为”这个动作有较深的主观色彩，其宾补部分必然要用不定式来表达。
                                                                                    ————来自Helr男神

stranquility

我觉得B选项是不是位置的问题，as放在among balabala 后面可能会引发歧义？
楼上关于consider A to be B 的 我没太看懂。。分不清“认为”和“看作”的区别。。。

jaydenpasson

我也没看懂...看作和认为的区别...所以 consider to be 可以用吗? 应该是不可以吧?

euphoria1

讲真，helr有的语法讲的很好，但有些固定搭配讲的莫名其妙