gwd31-9，倒装后是否仍符合逻辑主语一致的原则，请指教！

洛拉

and was后面就是一个完整的句子啊？and was deeply interested in Oriental themes.

觉得这道题应该选D，“，+and was"并不多余，一方面因为“was”与as many of his contemporaries “were”平行, 还有一方面，如果没有，后面deeply...就不完整，也不知道修饰谁了。and前面有逗号，因为主语之后的第一个谓语是was + 介词among结构，第二个谓语不是was + 介词结构了，而是一个was+ 形容词interested 构成的完整的系表结构中间加一个插入语，用逗号 + and was分开清楚明了。忘了好像在那个讨论贴里看见过说如果and前后两个动作的主语没有改变就不用逗号，但我看好多都是主语不变，and之前都有逗号，不过比较明显的特征是后面通常都有个插入语，我也不太说得清道理，只看到这种现象了。

A经过倒装之后，反而使句子的主语C S-S距离介词as+名词这个修饰成分太远了，按照OG中的说法，主语最好应当同时兼顾修饰成分和谓语。不知道说得对不对？

mymengming

  Camille SaintSaens (1835-1921) who was , (as many of his contemporaries were), deeply interested in Oriental themes, was among the most gifted and versatile musicians of his time as a pianist ,composer, scholar, and essayist on a variety of learned subjects.

        好像没有错的阿

     D, and链接的两个短句的意思好像不是很对称

盈儿

以下是引用gonghao在2006-5-17 16:19:00的发言：

肯定是D

A：As a pianist, composer, scholar, and essayist on a variety of learned subjects,among the most gifted and versatile musicians of his time was Camille Saint-Saens (1835-1921), who was 主语在哪里？？？

Camille Saint-Saens 应该就是主语,倒装了一下~

sabrina07

up

benu365

刚开始复习，通过大家讨论学到不少。
我倾向于D，感觉and前后很对称啊，去掉插入语以后
 Camille Saint-Saens was……, and was……。

chamcham

D

hhybigfool

a

heyii

    Pianist, composer, scholar and essayist on a variety of learned
    subjects,
  Saint-Saëns was among the most gifted and versatile musicians of his
  time, and deeply interested in Oriental themes
找到原句了。。。虽然D也不完全对，因为be动词应该省略。但是，BF说好像有个语法是一个人身兼数值要省略定冠词睇。。。

eileenmu木

我选D，但对于这个同位语前为什么不加冠词还是很不明白，求解。。。

[此贴子已经被作者于2008-3-30 9:24:45编辑过]

一尘

把这题顶出来，我的问题是d选项中，

“，”and was, as many of his contemporaries were, deeply...

还是 ，and was as many of his contemporaries were, deeply

完全晕了，到底and was后面的逗号在不在正确的句子里