到底是make A B 还是make it as(885-11-20)

fr6102790

20.   Byron possessed powers of observation that would have made him a great anthropologist and that makes his letters as a group the rival of the best novels of the time.

(A) makes his letters as a group the rival of

(B) makes his letters as a group one to rival

(C) makes his letters a group rivaling

(D) make his letters as a group the rival of（D）

(E) make his letters a group which is the rival of

看了以前的帖子不满意,问问题有没人解答,换个方法再问问看.

在LONGMAN上发现如下用法:

make it as
He was told he had no talent and would never make it as a professional singer.

想问是不是此题套用了这个短语,只不过把it换成his letters了?

fr6102790

来个联结,免得斑竹骂我没作过功课

http://forum.chasedream.com/dispbbs.asp?boardid=23&replyid=16325&id=16325&page=1&skin=0&Star=1

yukon

我看了连接，MM真能顶啊

我觉得是D,因为我觉得make his letters a group 不通，powers of observation怎么能把letters 变成a group呢？

fr6102790

我看了连接，MM真能顶啊

因为还有不到一个月时间考试,所以很着急,见笑了.

对这道题想了几天,觉得

在LONGMAN上发现如下用法:

make it as
He was told he had no talent and would never make it as a professional singer.

想问是不是此题套用了这个短语,只不过把it换成his letters了?

自己的想法行的通,YUKON,给点意见吧?

再帮忙看看我的这道题如何?(语法区的NN好象现在在放假中)

http://forum.chasedream.com/dispbbs.asp?boardid=23&id=100087&star=1#1158613

andrew_li

make it means manage to get something done. For instance,

I did not make it to the party last night.

means I did not go to the party last night.

make it as should not be treated as an idiom.

fr6102790

make it as should not be treated as an idiom.

不太明白Andrew的说法,你是说这个短语不是习惯用语吗? 可是这个短语是我从LONGMAN上找出来的,能说详细点吗

[此贴子已经被作者于2005-7-20 10:15:37编辑过]

WalkByFaith

It depends on:

1. In this situation: (D) make his letters as a group the rival of ,  'as a group' sounds more reasonable.

2. Sometime ake A B also works, e.g. make him a monster.

Personal idea, some gramma in English really has no rules as we chinese say '具体情况具体分析'.

只是一点拙见.

fr6102790

It depends on:

1. In this situation: (D) make his letters as a group the rival of ,  'as a group' sounds more reasonable.

2. Sometime ake A B also works, e.g. make him a monster.

Personal idea, some gramma in English really has no rules as we chinese say '具体情况具体分析'.

只是一点拙见.

什么意思啊,没闹明白???????

如果楼上的说的是make A as B, 则我不能同意,因为我已经确切的查过LONGMAN了,没有这个习惯用法.

[此贴子已经被作者于2005-7-20 15:29:20编辑过]

andrew_li

以下是引用fr6102790在2005-7-20 10:13:00的发言：
>

不太明白Andrew的说法,你是说这个短语不是习惯用语吗? 可是这个短语是我从LONGMAN上找出来的,能说详细点吗

make it is an idiom. make it as isn't.

fr6102790

make it is an idiom. make it as isn't.

But I really found this clause from LONGMAN?!