新G issue 105 菜鸟作文求批改 大谢~

vivienzhao0119

Claim: Imagination is a morevaluable asset than experience.
Reason: People who lackexperience are free to imagine what is possible without the constraints ofestablished habits and attitudes.
各位费神了，菜鸟在这90度鞠躬。吭吭哧哧写了一上午就这点东西，不知道大家有啥意见或建议。还有就是在secondly那块我写了个类似argument的东西，我同学说那个还是不写的好，不知道大家怎么看
This claim is related to a very controversial topic about thecomparison of importance to a person between imagination and experience. Einsteinonce said, imagination is more important than knowledge. The conclusion is drawnfor the consideration that a lack of experience lifts people out of establishedhabits and attitudes and sets them free to imagine. This argument makes senseto some extent, but I do not completely agree with the claim and the reason. fromthe following two aspects.
Admittedly, imagination plays important part in many fields. Einsteinonce put that experience is limited, while imagination summarized everything inthe world, and is the source of knowledge evolution. General relativity, forinstance, was discovered by doing a thought experiment in mind, than was onlyconfirmed scientific experiments. Not only in scientific work but also inliterary and artistic creation require a rich imagination. J.K.Rowling’s famousnovel series Harry Potter, which aremiracles in the history of literature, are filled with imagination and attractcountless readers. Today’s rapidly developing society needs such richimaginations to serve as a guide to creation.
It also should be recognized that established habits and attitudesmay sometimes shackle us with a chain. Philosophically speaking, there is noabsolute truth. The knowledge we learned may be wrong, and the experience wegot may be misleading. Imagination without establishedhabits and attitudes leads us closer to the truth. However,considering the following two aspects, the claim is proved to be one-sided.
Firstly, imagination is a very valuable asset to a person, butexperience is equally important, the reason put forward is not so true. Stilltake General relativity as an example. Einstein was a famous physicist and knowledgeable,he cannot do such thought experiment without a wealth of experience. A babyinfant cannot make any scientific discoveries just because he lacks experience.In most professions and academic fields, expertise and experience is the basisof innovation. One can only make more significative imagination in possess ofexperience, or it may be clueless.
In the second place, even if the reason is proved to be true, thereis no causal relationship between the reason and the claim. If experiencehinders the imagination, we can only obtain the conclusion that experienceleads to a lack of imagination, but not anything relates to which is morevaluable. And if we follow the logic of the claim and the reason, by putting upa reason that some experience helps to imagine, one can easily conclude thatexperience is a more valuable asset than imagination.
(In a nutshell) Consequently, the speaker overstates the importanceof imagination while overlooks the value of experience. To be successful, one mayfirst broaden his mind through experience, and then dialectically analyze it. Atlast, he can imagine and create boldly.

竹林中人

还是现在签到帖后面签个到吧

竹林中人

This claim 题目中是既有claim，也有reason的is relatedto a very controversial topic about the comparison of importance to a personbetween imagination and experience. Einstein once said, imagination is moreimportant than knowledge. The conclusion is drawn for the consideration that alack of experience lifts people out of established habits and attitudes andsets them free to imagine. This argument makes sense to some extent, but I donot completely agree with the claim and the reason. From the following twoaspects.这样的表述是很不地道的

Admittedly, imagination plays important part inmany fields. Einstein once put that experience is limited, while imaginationsummarized everything in the world, and is the source of knowledge evolution.General relativity, for instance, was discovered by doing a thought experimentin mind, than was only confirmed scientific experiments. Not only in scientificwork but also in literary and artistic creation require a rich imagination.J.K. Rowling’s famous novel series Harry Potter, which are miraclesin the history of literature, are filled with imagination and attract countlessreaders. Today’s rapidly developing society needs such rich imaginations toserve as a guide to creation. 在你说想象力的有很大作用的时候，你需要说下它具体是怎么作用的
It also should be recognized that establishedhabits and attitudes may sometimes shackle us with a chain. Philosophicallyspeaking, there is no absolute truth. The knowledge we learned may be wrong,and the experience we got may be misleading. Imagination without established habitsand attitudes leads us closer to the truth. However, considering the followingtwo aspects, the claim is proved to be one-sided.


Firstly, imagination is a very valuable asset to a person,but experience is equally important, the reason put forward is not so true.Still take General relativity as an example. Einstein was a famous physicistand knowledgeable, he cannot do such thought experiment without a wealth ofexperience. A baby infant cannot make any scientific discoveries just becausehe lacks experience. In most professions and academic fields, expertise andexperience is the basis of innovation. One can only make more significativeimagination in possess of experience, or it may be clueless.


In the second place, even if the reason is proved to betrue, there is no causal relationship between the reason and the claim. Ifexperience hinders the imagination, we can only obtain the conclusion thatexperience leads to a lack of imagination, but not anything relates to which ismore valuable. And if we follow the logic of the claim and the reason, byputting up a reason that some experience helps to imagine, one can easilyconclude that experience is a more valuable asset than imagination.
这后面的分析如果能有距离就更好了，因为说明想象力和知识经验的关系阐述起来比较抽象
(In a nutshell) Consequently, the speakeroverstates the importance of imagination while overlooks the value ofexperience. To be successful, one may first broaden his mind throughexperience, and then dialectically analyze it. At last, he can imagine andcreate boldly.
Actually you have done a good job。这种claim和reason的题目就是看你对他的质疑和反驳

vivienzhao0119

真是太谢谢了  其实很不知道写AW应该注意些什么....

vivienzhao0119

话说能分享签到贴的链接吗  ....  没找到....