OG12 Q100 指代问题 呼唤NN~~

半阙

100. The stars, some of them at tremendous speeds, are
motion just as the planets are, yet being so far away
from Earth that their apparent positions in the sky do
not change enough for their movement to be observe
during a single human lifetime.
(A) The stars, some of them at tremendous speeds
are in motion just as the planets are, yet being
(B) Like the planets, the stars are in motion, some
of them at tremendous speeds, but they are
(C) Although like the planets the stars are in motion
some of them at tremendous speeds, yet
(D) As the planets, the stars are in motion, some of
them at tremendous speeds, but they are
(E) The stars are in motion like the planets, some o
which at tremendous speeds are in motion but

  这题选B，用排除法很好做出来~但我想问的是B选项中some of them 指代不会有歧义么？可以指代planets也可以指代stars?  个人觉得应该改成some of which~~请教NN~~

半阙

大家帮忙顶一个啊~~

superbat28

some of them是独立主格的用法啊，我记得Manhattan里有写的。
正确的形式有以下几种：
The stars are in motion, some of which are at tremendous speeds.
The stars are in motion, some are at tremendous speeds.  ==> 应该是some at tremendous speeds
The stars are in motion, some of them at tremendous speeds.

也就是说如果你要变成which的话，后面跟着的应该是完整的从句，而非只是一个【介宾名词】

半阙

some of them是独立主格的用法啊，我记得Manhattan里有写的。
正确的形式有以下几种：
The stars are in motion, some of which are at tremendous speeds.
The stars are in motion, some are at tremendous speeds.
The stars are in motion, some of them at tremendous speeds.

也就是说如果你要变成which的话，后面跟着的应该是完整的从句，而非只是一个【介宾名词】

-- by 会员 superbat28 (2011/10/19 22:59:15)

原来some of them 是独立主格结构，之前我还真不知道。Manhattan就看过一个精简版的而且只看了一遍，果断力度不够啊~~~最后二十几天再恶补下语法，希望不要二战了~~谢谢bat~

半阙

some of them是独立主格的用法啊，我记得Manhattan里有写的。
正确的形式有以下几种：
The stars are in motion, some of which are at tremendous speeds.
The stars are in motion, some are at tremendous speeds.
The stars are in motion, some of them at tremendous speeds.

也就是说如果你要变成which的话，后面跟着的应该是完整的从句，而非只是一个【介宾名词】

-- by 会员 superbat28 (2011/10/19 22:59:15)

大蝙蝠~我今天在manhattan上看到啦~~按manhattan说，第二个句子应该是“The stars are in motion,some at tremendous speed“噢~~

superbat28

some of them是独立主格的用法啊，我记得Manhattan里有写的。
正确的形式有以下几种：
The stars are in motion, some of which are at tremendous speeds.
The stars are in motion, some are at tremendous speeds.
The stars are in motion, some of them at tremendous speeds.

也就是说如果你要变成which的话，后面跟着的应该是完整的从句，而非只是一个【介宾名词】

-- by 会员 superbat28 (2011/10/19 22:59:15)

大蝙蝠~我今天在manhattan上看到啦~~按manhattan说，第二个句子应该是“The stars are in motion,some at tremendous speed“噢~~

-- by 会员 半阙 (2011/10/26 19:22:12)

丢。。丢人了~哈哈
一着不慎，各种丢人~
半阙你是对的~第二个不应该有are的~
我。。悄悄地去墙角了。。

半阙

some of them是独立主格的用法啊，我记得Manhattan里有写的。
正确的形式有以下几种：
The stars are in motion, some of which are at tremendous speeds.
The stars are in motion, some are at tremendous speeds.
The stars are in motion, some of them at tremendous speeds.

也就是说如果你要变成which的话，后面跟着的应该是完整的从句，而非只是一个【介宾名词】

-- by 会员 superbat28 (2011/10/19 22:59:15)

大蝙蝠~我今天在manhattan上看到啦~~按manhattan说，第二个句子应该是“The stars are in motion,some at tremendous speed“噢~~

-- by 会员 半阙 (2011/10/26 19:22:12)

丢。。丢人了~哈哈
一着不慎，各种丢人~
半阙你是对的~第二个不应该有are的~
我。。悄悄地去墙角了。。

-- by 会员 superbat28 (2011/10/26 20:46:17)

,bat你应该这么偶尔的犯点小错，嗯...看上去正常一点~~~

酱子啊

some of them是独立主格的用法啊，我记得Manhattan里有写的。
正确的形式有以下几种：
The stars are in motion, some of which are at tremendous speeds.
The stars are in motion, some are at tremendous speeds.
The stars are in motion, some of them at tremendous speeds.

也就是说如果你要变成which的话，后面跟着的应该是完整的从句，而非只是一个【介宾名词】

-- by 会员 superbat28 (2011/10/19 22:59:15)

大蝙蝠~我今天在manhattan上看到啦~~按manhattan说，第二个句子应该是“The stars are in motion,some at tremendous speed“噢~~

-- by 会员 半阙 (2011/10/26 19:22:12)

丢。。丢人了~哈哈
一着不慎，各种丢人~
半阙你是对的~第二个不应该有are的~
我。。悄悄地去墙角了。。

-- by 会员 superbat28 (2011/10/26 20:46:17)

,bat你应该这么偶尔的犯点小错，嗯...看上去正常一点~~~

-- by 会员 半阙 (2011/10/27 9:46:06)

是的，独立主格，即名词加名词的形式，说的好。。。。赞

lovepunch

some of them是独立主格的用法啊，我记得Manhattan里有写的。
正确的形式有以下几种：
The stars are in motion, some of which are at tremendous speeds.
The stars are in motion, some are at tremendous speeds.
The stars are in motion, some of them at tremendous speeds.

也就是说如果你要变成which的话，后面跟着的应该是完整的从句，而非只是一个【介宾名词】

-- by 会员 superbat28 (2011/10/19 22:59:15)

大蝙蝠~我今天在manhattan上看到啦~~按manhattan说，第二个句子应该是“The stars are in motion,some at tremendous speed“噢~~

-- by 会员 半阙 (2011/10/26 19:22:12)

丢。。丢人了~哈哈
一着不慎，各种丢人~
半阙你是对的~第二个不应该有are的~
我。。悄悄地去墙角了。。

-- by 会员 superbat28 (2011/10/26 20:46:17)

,bat你应该这么偶尔的犯点小错，嗯...看上去正常一点~~~

-- by 会员 半阙 (2011/10/27 9:46:06)

是的，独立主格，即名词加名词的形式，说的好。。。。赞

-- by 会员 酱子啊 (2011/10/27 12:59:32)

最近大家都在看Matt啊，看来是我out了

"也就是说如果你要变成which的话，后面跟着的应该是完整的从句，而非只是一个【介宾名词】"受用！！谢谢~~

林水监

哈哈~~受用受用