求助 prep 24 新问 关于比较中的时态问题

mia113

Employment costs rose 2.8 percent in the 12 months that ended in September, slightly less than

they did in the year that ended in the previous quarter.

(A) less than they did

(B) less than it did

(C) less than they were

(D) lower than

(E) lower than they were

（A）

198. Although Napoleon’s army entered Russia with far more supplies than they had in their previous campaigns, it had provisions for only twenty-four days.

(A) they had in their previous campaigns

(B) their previous campaigns had had

(C) they had for any previous campaign

(D)in their previous campaigns

(E) for any previous campaign

（E）
想请问下24中的正确答案A，中did的用法是不是有点不妥， 因为比较的时间是 in the 12 months that ended in Spetember,和 in the year that ended in the previous quarter，很明显 后面一个时间是在前一个时间之前·前面用了rose过去时，那么比较中they did应该是 they had done/risen吧？

比方说OG198里，上面的例子排除A除了里面的they指代错误， 动词had也应该是had had
大家觉得了？

(E) for any previous campaign

（E）
想请问下24中的正确答案A，中did的用法是不是有点不妥， 因为比较的时间是 in the 12 months that ended in Spetember,和 in the year that ended in the previous quarter，很明显 后面一个时间是在前一个时间之前·前面用了rose过去时，那么比较中they did应该是 they had done/risen吧？

比方说OG198里，上面的例子排除A除了里面的they指代错误， 动词had也应该是had had
大家觉得了？

bitieming

这道题考点是动词并列，结构为A rose...in..., less than B did(rose) in...
所以did应该与rose并列，两个动作的确是前后发生，但是不存在前后逻辑关系，只是程度上的对比。
反观198题并不存在动词的并列。
个人看法，希望能帮到LZ

mia113

这道题考点是动词并列，结构为A rose...in..., less than B did(rose) in...
所以did应该与rose并列，两个动作的确是前后发生，但是不存在前后逻辑关系，只是程度上的对比。
反观198题并不存在动词的并列。
个人看法，希望能帮到LZ

-- by 会员 bitieming (2011/7/26 17:57:40)

o o ````非常感谢楼上···讲得很清楚哟····

塔罗牌

我想知道第2个题 为什么不选D呢

mia113

因为army是单数  不能用their